2008 DRAFT PICKS 2008 REPORT CARD
followed by workout numbers
2008 TEAM NEEDS
prior to free agency
2007 DRAFT PICKS 2007 REPORT CARD
followed by comments & workout numbers
2007 TEAM NEEDS
prior to free agency
2006 Draft Picks 2006 Draft Report Card 2006 Team Needs
2005 Draft Picks 2005 Draft Report Card 2005 Draft Team News
2004 Draft

2003 Draft

2002 Draft

Click here to load 900 Football Links Home Page

2008 DRAFT PICKS
links go to NFL.com website

Arizona
Rd Sel# Player Pos. Ht. Wt. School Jay's ranking Jay's draft value
1 23 Rashard Mendenhall RB 5'10.1" 225 Illinois #2 RB Round 1
2 53 Limas Sweed WR 6'3.7" 215 Texas #2 WR Round 1
3 88 Bruce Davis DE/OLB 6'2.5" 252 UCLA #15 DE Round 3/Round 4
4 130 Tony Hills OT 6'5.1" 309 Texas #11 OT Round 3
5 156 Dennis Dixon QB 6'2.3" 195 Oregon   Late Round Value
6 188 Mike Humpal OLB/ILB 6'2.4" 244 Iowa #13 OLB Round 4/Round 5
6 194 Ryan Mundy FS/CB 6'1" 215 W Virginia   Late Round Value
FA   Travis Williams CB/Ret 5'9.3" 186 E Carolina   Late Round Value
FA   Jordan Reffett DT/DE 6'5.2" 292 Washington   Late Round Value/Free Agent
FA   Michah Rucker WR 6'5.5" 217 E Illinois   Late Round Value

top

B+

2008 COLLEGE DRAFT REPORT CARD

by Jay Goldberg

The Steelers came into the draft needing help along their offensive line early, but the board didn't line up for them and instead they got two of the biggest steals in the draft in rounds one and two.  They did draft former tight end Hills in round four and he has potential but isn't NFL-ready right now.  There were some options along the line the Steelers could have added in rounds five and six, but the players they drafted are fine.  I did think they would have gone after players like Tyler Polumbus and Robert Felton in free agency.  While no sure things, players of this ilk would have been worth a look in camp.

DRAFT PICKS

When looking back at this draft, Mendenhall could be the best every down back to come out of this draft (McFadden will be the best playmaker).  The timing for drafting a player like Mendenhall who is big, fast, quick, runs well inside and outside, and is a good receiver was perfect.  Fast Willie Parker is coming off injury and is coming off back to back seasons of over 300 carries.  He is not a big back and being in the top five in carries for two straight years could start to take its toll on him.  Mendenhall could become option one in a two-back system sooner than many people think.

Sweed was a steal in round two.  Just like with Mendenhall, when looking back at this draft, Sweed could be the best receiver to come out of this draft.  Sweed has excellent hands, very good speed for a big receiver, and is a top athlete.  At almost 6'4" with a 37.5" vertical, Big Ben and him can play catch above defensive back heads.  

Davis was very productive at UCLA at defensive end, especially as a pass rusher, but may lack the quickness and change-of-direction skills to play outside linebacker in the Steeler's 3-4 defense and is much too small to play end in a 3-4.  Of course if the Steelers ever go back to a 4-3, the system Tomlin favored prior to becoming Pittsburgh's head coach, he could be a good pass rushing defensive end.

Hills is an athletic offensive tackle who is a converted tight end.  He still is a bit of a work in progress, but has the tools to develop into a quality starter.

Dixon is an excellent athlete who got injured late in his senior year and will likely sit out this year.  Down the line he could give Pittsburgh an interesting developmental quarterback, who could play multiple roles while learning to play under center.  In the spread offense as a senior he completed two-thirds of his passes.

Humpal was thought to be a player who had limited athletic ability and got by on smarts and hard work.  However, his workout shows that he is a pretty good athlete who is quick and has decent speed.  He will be a very good special teams and solid backup.

Like most of the Steelers' picks, Mundy was a productive player in college.  He is a heady player with good strength.  He is also a terrific athlete who changes direction well and will be a top special teams player.  He has potential a safety as well.

COLLEGE STREET FREE AGENTS

Williams is an undersized corner who plays faster and quicker on the field than he times.  Early in his college career he was a top punt returner and may need to show that skill to stick.  If not, he is a good candidate for the Steelers' practice squad.

Reffett is a good kid who picked a good situation for him.  He plays the run better than the pass but is undersized (bulk) for a run-stuffing defensive tackle.  However, he has the perfect frame for defensive end in the 3-4.  He faces long odds, but is a hard worker.

Rucker has good size, is an excellent athlete, and was productive at Eastern Illinois.  I predict he will stick on the Steelers' practice squad.  He is a couple of years away but could develop into a #4 receiver and special teams player.

red indicates workout number in top range at position in draft
(blue college name indicates workout #'s include Pro Day numbers)

COMBINE
YES
FIRST NAME SCHOOL HEIGHT WEIGHT BENCH 40 10 20 SHORT LONG 3 CONE VERT BROAD
Mendenhall Rashard ILLINOIS 5'10.1" 225 26 4.45 1.57 2.59 4.18 NA NA 33.5" 9'9"
Sweed Limas TEXAS 6'3.7" 215 NA 4.48 1.54 2.62 4.33 NA NA 37.5" 10'8"
Davis Bruce UCLA 6'2.5" 252 19 4.72 1.59 2.74 4.47 NA 7.34 32" 9'11"
Hills Tony TEXAS 6'5.1" 309 24 NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
Dixon Dennis OREGON 6'2.3" 195 NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
Humpal Mike IOWA 6'2.4" 244 20 4.68 1.63 2.75 4.19 NA 7.00 38" 10'2"
Mundy Ryan W VIRGINIA 6'1" 215 21 4.55 1.59 2.62 4.33 NA 6.81 36" 10'10"
Williams Travis E CAROLINA 5'9.3" 186 16 4.44 1.51 2.56 4.21 NA 6.98 33.5" 10'0"
Reffett Jordan WASHINGTON 6'5.2" 292 NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
Rucker Michah E ILLINOIS 6'5.5" 217 NA 4.47 1.50 2.58 4.47 NA 6.90 39" 11'3"

2008 NEEDS PRIOR TO DRAFT AND FREE AGENCY

PIT          Major Need          Need          Upgrade         Depth Need         Not a Need

QB  With Roethlisberger and Batch, the Steelers are in excellent shape at quarterback.  However, this may be the year that Pittsburgh invests in a quarterback late in the draft to develop as a future backup for Big Ben.
RB  Parker is coming off of an injury, and Davenport had good moments and not-so-good moments as his backup.  Davis could expand his role in 2008.  Look for the Steelers to add a big back who can be used in short yardage and goal line situations and challenge Davenport for the primary backup role.
WR  Holmes came on strong and is on his way to becoming an elite receiver.  Ward is still very effective.  Wilson and Washington are good, speedy backups, but a quick slot receiver could be added.  It was hoped Reid would play that role, but it hasn't happened yet.
TE Miller is one of the best tight ends in the league.  Spaeth can catch and is a willing blocker.  Tuman is a free agent.  Dekker is on hand to replace him.  If Tuman leaves, a tight end will be brought in to challenge Dekker.
OL  This unit underachieved in 2007 and Faneca and top backup Starks are free agents.  The Steelers could draft a center or guard to replace Mahan (Simmons could move to center), a guard to replace Faneca, and a tackle to challenge Colon (right side).
DL If Smith comes back healthy, this unit is fine.  Keisel is a bit undersized but McBean may challenge him in camp.  Hampton is still a solid run-stuffer.  The Steelers could use depth at both end and nose.
LB Still a strength for Pittsburgh.  Harrison was great in his first year as a starter.  Haggans is a free agent who will be shown the door so Woodley can start.  Farrior is still very effective.  Foote will have to hold off Timmons to keep his starting job in 2008.  The Steelers may look for some backups, but that's it.
DB Townsend, Taylor, McFadden and Gay are a nice foursome heading into next year.  However, if a stud corner can be secured the group could be upgraded.  Polamalu, Smith and Carter are good safeties and Clark is expected back.
ST Outside of Reed, this area needs to improve in 2008.  Sepulveda, a fourth round pick last year, showed enough to be the punter again.  Bodies need to be added who can play on coverage teams, and a return man will be added.  Rossum and Reid are replaceable.

top

2007 DRAFT PICKS
links go to NFL.com website

Rd Sel# Player Pos. Ht. Wt. School Jay's Ranking Jay's Draft Value
1 15 Timmons, Lawrence OLB 6-3 232 Florida State # 3 OLB Round 2
2 46 Woodley, LaMarr DE 6-2 269 Michigan #13 DE Round 3
3 77 Spaeth, Matt TE 6-7 267 Minnesota # 7 TE Round 4
4 112 Sepulveda, Daniel P 6-3 229 Baylor # 1 P Late Round Value
4 132 McBean, Ryan DE 6-5 290 Oklahoma State # 8 DT Round 3
5 156 Stephenson, Cameron G 6-3 306 Rutgers Late Round Value
5 170 Gay, William CB 5-10 187 Louisville Late Round Value
7 227 Baker, Dallas WR 6-3 207 Florida # 21 WR Round 4
FA Capizzi, Jason OT 6-9 324 Indiana (PA) Late Round Value
FA Fowler, Eric WR 6-3 215 Grand Valley St Off My Board
FA Jones, Derick DE 6-4 282 Grand Valley St Off My Board

 

C

2007 COLLEGE DRAFT REPORT CARD

by Jay Goldberg

The Steelers had most of their top draft picks rated slightly higher than me.  They did get good value with McBean and Baker on day two.  In addition, no college street free agents jumped out at me.

I had a second round grade on Timmons, not a first round grade.  However, if drafted as a SAM in a 4-3, I could see him being grabbed in round one.  As an outside linebacker in a 3-4 he shows potential, but it is no sure thing that he will develop into a big time pass rusher.  Therefore, if the Steelers switch to a 4-3 in the next year or two (Tomlin's preferred defense), then this pick (and draft grade) will have to be re-visited.  Woodley is another OLB projection.  He was a productive sacker in college at defensive end, goes all out on the field, and is a hard worker.  I had a third round grade on him because he is a bit short for a 4-3 defensive end and needs work if moving to OLB in a 4-3.  He also has the look of "New England Patriot" defensive-end turned inside linebacker in a 3-4 defense ala Bruschi and Vrabel.  Spaeth is a big target with reliable hands and is an excellent blocker.  He is clearly the number two tight end on this team behind Heath Miller.  He should contribute immediately as a blocking tight end and goal line target but his upside for Pittsburgh is limited by the of Miller.  With the lack of depth behind Parker, my choice here would have been running back Antonio Pittman.  Spaeth may have been available in round four (and Patrick would have been available at tight end in round five).   Sepulveda was my top rated punter in the draft.  I like the selection of McBean.  He looked good playing end in Senior Bowl practices and should make the move there very well for the Steelers.  McBean reacts well to the ball and is quick and could develop into a pass rush threat form his 3-4 end position as well.  Stephenson played offensive and defensive tackle before settling in at guard.  He is a very tough, strong kid who needs some work but should develop into a good run blocker.   Gay should be a solid special teas player with the ability to be a dime back.  He is more quick than fast which will allow him to line up in the slot.  Baker was a great get in round seven.  He is a tough kid with good hands and quickness.  He will develop into a solid number three receiver.  All he lacks is home run speed, but he will get open, catch the ball, and move the chains.

The Steelers didn't sign any college street free agents that made me go wow.  Capizzi is a prime candidate for Pittsburgh's development squad.  He is a big kid who needs work but could develop into a backup tackle.  Fowler, a tall wide receiver, is worth a look in camp.  He had a monster senior year and is another candidate for the Steelers' development squad.  Jones is mentioned because the Steelers' obviously saw something in him while watching tape on Fowler.  He has the size to play end in a 3-4 defense.

red indicates workout number in top range at position in draft

COMBINE
YES

 

COLLEGE

POS HGHT WGHT BENCH