2008 DRAFT PICKS 2008 REPORT CARD
followed by workout numbers
2008 TEAM NEEDS
prior to free agency
2007 DRAFT PICKS 2007 REPORT CARD
followed by comments & workout numbers
2007 TEAM NEEDS
prior to free agency
2006 Draft Picks 2006 Draft Report Card 2006 Team Needs
2005 Draft Picks 2005 Draft Report Card 2005 Draft Team News
2004 Draft

2003 Draft

2002 Draft

Click here to load 900 Football Links Home Page

2008 DRAFT PICKS
links go to NFL.com website

Arizona
Rd Sel# Player Pos. Ht. Wt. School Jay's ranking Jay's draft value
1 10 Jerod Mayo ILB 6.1.6" 242 Tennessee #1 ILB Round 1
2 62 Terrence Wheatley CB/Ret 5'9.5" 187 Colorado #16 CB Round 4
3 78 Shawn Crable DE/OLB 6'4" 245 Michigan #17 DE Round 4
3 94 Kevin O'Connell QB 6'5" 223 S Diego St #8 QB Round 4

Player who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher than him.

O'Connell is a tall, athletic kid who throws very well on the move.  He will need time to develop but has too much upside to risk on a team's development squad (where he can be plucked off by another team).  At 6'5", O'Connell ran for 408 yards his senior year.  I believe he will be a Matt Hasselbeck-type of quarterback down the line.
5 153 Matt Slater S/WR/Ret 5'11" 195 UCLA   Free Agent
6 197 Bo Ruud OLB/ILB 6'3.3" 234 Nebraska   Late Round Value
FA   BenJarvis Green-Ellis RB 5'10.5" 219 Mississippi   Late Round Value
FA   Gary Guyton OLB/ILB 6'1.5" 245 Geo Tech #9 OLB Round 4
FA   Vince Redd OLB/DE 6'4.4" 253 Liberty   Late Round Value

top

C+

2008 COLLEGE DRAFT REPORT CARD

by Jay Goldberg

While the Pats addressed their biggest need areas, there were some corners and outside rush linebackers available at #62 and #78 that I liked slightly more than Wheatley and Crable.  I also believe Slater would have been available in round 6 (and even free agency, but obviously the Pats didn't want to risk that given his fifth round selection), which would have resulted in the Pats getting a better player than Ruud, who I actually have a lower grade on than their college street free agent Guyton.

DRAFT PICKS

Mayo was a good and needed pick in round one.  He is an active linebacker with good speed, quickness and athleticism.  I thought he would fit best as a WILL in a 4-3 since he is at his best when the defensive line can engage blockers so he can roam free to make plays.  However, he can take on blockers and fight them off to make tackles so he will be just fine in the Pats' 3-4 defense.  Mayo will be a good player, but don't expect the next Patrick Willis.

Wheatley is a short corner with good speed, athleticism and change-of-direction skills.  He is quick enough to play the slot and has a good nose for the ball.  He is also a tough kid who plays injured and likes to hit.  That said, I thought Charles Godfrey, another tough kid, displayed better cover skills during Senior Bowl practices, is two inches taller and therefore matches up better outside. 

Crable was a defensive end in college and projects as an outside linebacker in the Pats' 4-3 defense.  While Crable has the pass rush skills to transition to that position, he lacks the athleticism and quickness to be anything more than a pass rusher in that defense.  He will have trouble dropping back in coverage.  Personally, I think Cliff Avril would have been the ideal pick here.

O'Connell caught my eye in a good way during the college post-season.  He is a tall, athletic kid, who throws well on the move and has the potential to be a starter in the NFL down the line (not that he'll get the chance with the Pats).  He should develop into a quality backup and could even bring value down the line in a trade.  I like his upside more than Cassell and Gutierrez.

Slater was on New England's radar, but I'm not sure if he was more than a minor blip with other teams.  The Pats thinking is that he is the next Troy Brown.  He has played both receiver and defensive back, is a good special teams player, and a very good return man.  Was this high for him?  Yes.  Does that mean it was a bad pick?  No.  Personally, I would have waited a round to select Slater (assuming he was a priority like he was for the Pats) and grabbed the talented but risky offensive lineman Carl Nicks.

Ruud is a player who may have a hard time making the team.  He projects inside and has good speed.  If he makes the team he should be a staple on special teams. 

COLLEGE STREET FREE AGENTS

Green-Ellis is a strong, powerful back who could just steal a roster spot as a goal-line and short-yardage runner.

I like Guyton's potential more than Ruud's and expect him to pass Ruud on the depth chart during training camp.  Guyton is faster and a better athlete than Ruud.

Redd is ideal for the Pat's practice squad.  He has the speed and athleticism to play outside in the 3-4, but will need time to develop, and will need to get stronger.

red indicates workout number in top range at position in draft
(blue college name indicates workout #'s include Pro Day numbers)

COMBINE
YES
FIRST NAME SCHOOL HEIGHT WEIGHT BENCH 40 10 20 SHORT LONG 3 CONE VERT BROAD
Mayo Jerod TENNESSEE 6'1.6" 242 22 4.54 1.51 2.58 4.29 NA 7.31 40.5" 9'6"
Wheatley Terrence COLORADO 5'9.5" 187 17 4.37 1.48 2.50 4.20 NA 6.74 38.5" 10'8"
Crable Shawn MICHIGAN 6'4" 245 29 4.61 1.56 2.70 4.55 NA 7.29 28" 9'3"
O'Connell Kevin SAN DIEGO ST 6'5" 223 NA 4.57 1.60 2.71 4.38 NA 7.01 31" 9'5"
Wilhite Jonathan AUBURN 5'9.4" 184 20 4.38 1.46 2.50 4.41 NA 7.17 35" 10'0"
Slater Matt UCLA 5'11" 195 NA 4.40 NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
Ruud Bo NEBRASKA 6'3'3" 234 18 4.60 1.53 2.61 4.71 NA 7.30 32.5" 9'10"
Green-Ellis BenJarvus MISSISSIPPI 5'10.5" 219 24 4.55 1.60 2.68 4.50 NA 7.56 34" 9'8"
Guyton Gary GEORGIA TECH 6'1.5" 245 16 4.47 1.46 2.53 4.33 11.57 7.07 40" 10'6"
Redd Vince LIBERTY 6'4.4" 253 13 4.56 1.56 2.58 NA NA NA 39" 9'10"

2008 NEEDS PRIOR TO DRAFT AND FREE AGENCY

NE          Major Need          Need          Upgrade         Depth Need         Not a Need

QB  Brady is as good as it gets.  The Pats seem happy with Cassel, at least most of the time.  Gutierrez will get competition for his spot. 
RB  Maroney is a good young back.  Faulk, Morris and Evans provide quality depth.  The Pats may bring in a player to fight for a backup role.
WR  Moss, Stallworth and Gaffney are all free agents.  What the Pats need here will depend on who they bring back.  I expect it will be Moss and Gaffney.
TE Watson is a very good tight end.  Brady is getting up in age.  Depth is needed at this position, in particular, a blocking tight end.
OL  The Pats offensive line had three Pro Bowlers, but was manhandled by the Giants.  If the Pats return the same line they will be fine.  However, if they can upgrade with a mobile player with better size, they will jump at the chance.
DL The Pats' starting defensive line is a strength.  Green is a good sub, but the line suffers when he starts.  Depth at nose tackle is also needed.
LB Thomas and Vrabel are two excellent starters who will be back.  Bruschi and Seau are free agents and getting up there in years.  The Pats are thin behind these four, except for Colvin who is coming back from injury and has a big price tag.  They need to add at least one new starter, even if Bruschi and Seau come back.  The Pats are in a position to add the best linebacker who fits their system since Thomas can play inside or outside.  They also need to add some young linebackers for depth.
DB Samuel, Gay and Wilson are free agents.  If Samuel and Gay leave, the team will need to add a corner who can start.  Meriweather backs up both corner and safety, but long term should be more dominate at free safety.  Even if just one of the two free agent corners leaves, the Pats will need to add a corner for depth (and one who could push Hobbs to start).  At safety, Harrison keeps plugging away, Sanders made good progress, and Meriweather is a future star.  A young backup safety could be added.  Harrison is old and has a history of injury.
ST The Pats are fine here, however, players to push the starters could be brought in for all.

top

2007 DRAFT PICKS
links go to NFL.com website

Rd Sel# Player Pos. Ht. Wt. School Jay's ranking Jay's Draft Value
1 24 Meriweather, Brandon FS 5-11 192 Miami (Fla.) # 3 FS Round 1
4 127 Brown, Kareem DT 6-4 290 Miami (Fla.) # 7 DT Round 3
5 171 Oldenburg, Clint OT 6-6 300 Colorado State Late Round Value
6 180 Rogers, Justin OLB 6-3 262 Southern Methodist Off My Board
6 202 Richardson, Mike CB 5-11 188 Notre Dame Late Round Value
6 208 Hairston, Justise RB 6-1 222 Central Connecticut Off My Board
6 209 Hilliard, Corey OT 6-5 318 Oklahoma State Late Round Value
7 211 Lua, Oscar ILB 6-1 245 Southern California Off My Board
7 247 Elgin, Mike G 6-3 291 Iowa Late Round Value
FA Nordin, Jake TE 6-3 261 Northern Illinois Late Round Value
FA Anam, Larry CB 5-11 190 Boston College Late Round Value
FA Gutierrez, Matt QB 6-4 227 Idaho State Off My Board

 

C

2007 COLLEGE DRAFT REPORT CARD

by Jay Goldberg

The Patriots did most of their work in free agency and trades.  The grade here represents the players drafted.  If Randy Moss was included in this grade it would jump to A-.  Moss will be great with the Pats.  After their first two picks the Pats draft board differed greatly from mine.  

Meriweather was a great pick by the Pats.  He is a rare playmaking free safety who can step out and cover receivers like a corner when needed.  Other corners can cover because of speed, but Meriweather covers with cornerback skills.  Brown was another excellent get.  He fits the mold of prior drafted Patriot lineman, a slightly undersized run-stuffing defensive tackle who will make a solid defensive end in their 3-4 defense.  Brown should be a rotation player this year.  Oldenburg is a smart former tight end who needs work but has enough skills to be a good development squad candidate.  He could grow into a valuable reserve.  There was no offensive tackle on the board who was clearly better, although I like the potential of Michael Otto more.  Rogers is a defensive end who the Pats will try at inside linebacker.  Most 3-4 teams look for defensive ends to be rush outside ends in their 3-4, but the Pats have been successful moving defensive ends to inside linebacker.  He was off my board as an end and outside linebacker but I'll give the Pats a pass with him inside because of their successful track record.  Richardson has the tools of of day one cornerback but got beat too often at Notre Dame.  He is a project, but one that could pay dividends.  Hairston was stud at Central Connecticut.  He is more quick than fast and his college production made him deserving of getting a long look in some team's training camp.  Personally, I liked Jackie Battle much better and feel he should have been the Pats' pick here.  He would have definitely made the team and been a contributor in year one.  Hairston will probably end up on their development squad.  Hilliard is a strong kid who needs work on his technique but could develop into a solid right tackle down the line.  Lua is a heady player who has not rebounded fully from his knee injury.  In his senior year he lost his job.  His best bet was with a 3-4 team and that is where he ended up.  He may be placed on IR.  Elgin is an athletic center who may be the best of the three offensive lineman drafted by New England.  He needs to hit the weight room but could be a pleasant surprise in a couple of years.

The Pats have depth so they didn't get a lot of the top college street free agents.  Jake Nordin is a tough kid who can block and has reliable hands.  He lacks speed and quickness.  He is an ideal backup blocking tight end who can also surprise with a touchdown catch in goal line offenses.  Anam is a top athlete with good size and speed.  He will be an excellent special teams player while learning his craft.  He could stick on their roster or make their development squad.  I expected more of Gutierrez in the post season all star games.  He disappointed me (and obviously NFL teams as well).  His performance dropped him off my board.  He is probably just a camp arm but at one time he was an intriguing late round sleeper.

red indicates workout number in top range at position in draft

COMBINE
YES

 

COLLEGE

POS HGHT