2008 DRAFT PICKS 2008 REPORT CARD
followed by workout numbers
2008 TEAM NEEDS
prior to free agency
2007 DRAFT PICKS 2007 REPORT CARD
followed by comments & workout numbers
2007 TEAM NEEDS
prior to free agency
2006 Draft Picks 2006 Draft Report Card 2006 Team Needs
2005 Draft Picks 2005 Draft Report Card 2005 Draft Team News
2004 Draft

2003 Draft

2002 Draft

Click here to load 900 Football Links Home Page

2008 DRAFT PICKS
links go to NFL.com website

Arizona
Rd Sel# Player Pos. Ht. Wt. School Jay's ranking Jay's draft value
1 8 Derrick Harvey DE 6'4.5" 271 Florida #3 DE Round 1
2 52 Quentin Groves DE/OLB 6'3.1" 250 Auburn #6 DE Round 2
5 155 Thomas Williams OLB 6'0.7" 238 USC   Late Round Value/Free Agent
5 159 Trae Williams CB 5'9" 193 S Florida   Late Round Value/Free Agent
6 213 Chauncey Washington RB 5'11.3" 211 USC #14 RB Round 4
FA   Adam Bishop TE 6'4" 243 Nevado-Reno   Late Round Value
FA   Isaiah Gardner CB/S 5'11.1" 197 Maryland #22 CB Round 4/Round 5
FA   Paul Smith QB 6'1.2" 208 Tulsa   Late Round Value/Free Agent
FA   Brian Witherspoon CB/Ret 5'10.3" 175 Stillman   Late Round Value

top

B

2008 COLLEGE DRAFT REPORT CARD

by Jay Goldberg

Many will question the Jags giving up lots of goodies to move up to grab Harvey.  I will not.  He is a needed piece to their puzzle and they are a team that will be in the Super Bowl hunt.  Where I do question their draft is in round five where big defensive tackle Ahytba Rubin was available and would have provided them with a big run-stuffer to rotate in with Henderson.  I know they like Meier and Landri, but both are on the light side for defensive tackles.  The Jags also signed some quality college street free agents.

DRAFT PICKS

Harvey should beat out Spicer sooner rather than later and become a quality starter who holds his own against the run while getting between 8 and 12 sacks a year.  He is a good addition to their team.

Groves is a terrific athlete with speed and pass rushing abilities.  I thought he would go to a team that plays a 3-4 and move to outside linebacker.  For the Jags he should become a vital part of their nickel defense.  I can see the Jags moving Harvey inside in the nickel to play a Justin-Tuck-role with Groves replacing him at end.

Thomas Williams is a player whose upside is as a versatile backup and quality special teams player.  He played inside and outside at USC.

Trae Williams is an undersized corner who displayed good man to man skills at South Florida, but may have trouble maintaining those skills against NFL wideouts.

Washington was an excellent pick in round six.  I noted that it may have been time for the Jags to draft a strong runner to pair with Jones-Drew down the line after Taylor retires.  Washington is a tough, strong inside runner with good but little wiggle.  He could fit nicely in a year or two as the change-of-pace power back to spell Jones-Drew.

COLLEGE STREET FREE AGENTS

Bishop is a heady player with good hands and is an above average blocker.  He is limited athletically and will not stretch the field but has potential as a #3 tight end who can block and catch short passes off blocking formations.

I like Gardner's potential more than Trae Williams' potential.  Gardner was known as a physical player and was thought to be limited physically.  Then he put together an eye-opening workout.  Apparently he has good speed and quickness and is a tremendous athlete.  Add to that he tied for eighth in the ACC and 79th in the nation in passes defended and the Jags just may have a free agent steal.

Smith is an undersized quarterback with good mobility, good smarts, and good accuracy.  He is the type of player that keeps hanging around and when given a chance performs better than expected.

Witherspoon is extremely fast and a top athlete.  He has mad return skills and should be fun to watch in early preseason.  To help on defense he will have to hit the weight room, he does have good ball skills in the secondary.  He is an intriguing player.

red indicates workout number in top range at position in draft
(blue college name indicates workout #'s include Pro Day numbers)

COMBINE
YES
FIRST NAME SCHOOL HEIGHT WEIGHT BENCH 40 10 20 SHORT LONG 3 CONE VERT BROAD
Harvey Derrick FLORIDA 6'4.5" 271 31 4.80 1.64 2.78 4.36 NA 7.27 31" 9'5"
Groves Quentin AUBURN 6'3.1" 250 30 4.52 1.57 2.68 4.42 NA 7.31 35" 10'0"
Williams Thomas USC 6'0.7" 238 26 4.88 1.64 2.81 NA NA NA 29.5" 9'5"
Williams Trae S FLORIDA 5'9" 193 NA 4.48 1.54 2.59 4.37 NA 7.03 33" 9'2"
Washington Chauncy USC 5'11.3" 211 18 4.40 1.51 2.53 4.58 NA 7.53 36" 9'11"
Bishop Adam NEV-RENO 6'4" 243 22 4.93 1.69 2.88 4.28 NA 7.14 27" 9'5"
Gardner Isaiah MARYLAND 5'11.1" 197 16 4.40 1.48 2.53 4.12 NA 6.99 42.5" 11'0"
Smith Paul TULSA 6'1.2" 208 NA 4.94 1.64 2.87 4.29 NA 7.02 26.5" 9'2"
Witherspoon Brian STILLMAN 5'10.3" 175 NA 4.29 1.42 2.51 4.36 NA 6.86 40" 10'10"

2008 NEEDS PRIOR TO DRAFT AND FREE AGENCY

JAC       Major Need          Need          Upgrade         Depth Need         Not a Need

QB  Garrad showed that he is a very good quarterback, one a team can go deep into the playoffs with.  Gray is a free agent so a backup could be needed.  In fact, even if Gray comes back, a backup is needed.
RB  Taylor and Jones-Drew are an excellent one-two punch.  Greg Jones has shown good run skills in the past.  In a deep running back draft it may be time for the Jags to draft a younger big back to share the load with Jones-Drew in a couple of years.
WR  I wonder if the Jags are as tired of the word potential as I am.  The Jags have used a lot of high draft picks on receivers and have not uncovered a bonafide star.  Williams and Jones remain works in progress.  Wilford is a free agent.  Northcutt should be a third or fourth wideout, not a starter.  Walker and Broussard are the latest Jag receivers with "potential".  The Jags desperately need to add a legit #1.
TE Lewis started coming on.  He'll be a good one.  Wrighster has to come back from a tough injury.  Depth is needed.
OL  Solid unit with good players, but upgrades are possible all along the line.   Also, Williams will probably leave in free agency so a player to compete for a backup tackle position is needed.  
DL What was once a strength, now is a need area.  Henderson is still a stud inside, but Stroud and Hayward haven't been the same since surgery.  Meier is best suited as a sub. McCary is a free agent and has only had one good year.  Landri has potential and Spicer is a solid, but replaceable starter.  A starting end and a player to push to start at tackle are needed. 
LB Some like this unit better than me.  I love the rookie Durant.  He'll be a good one.  But Smith and Ingram are solid, but replaceable players.  Mike Peterson is a top linebacker but injuries and age are catching up to him.
DB No problems here.  Mathis and Williams are a top pair of corners and Nelson and Sensabaugh are excellent young safeties.  Knight played well when Sensabaugh got hurt.  A corner to compete for the nickel and another young safety could be added.
ST The kicking and return games are fine.  Competition for long snapper Zelenka will probably be brought in.

 

2007 DRAFT PICKS
links go to NFL.com website

Rd Sel# Player Pos. Ht. Wt. School Jay's ranking Jay's Draft Value
1 21 Nelson, Reggie FS 6-0 193 Florida # 2 FS Round 1
2 48 Durant, Justin ILB 6-1 235 Hampton # 5 ILB Round 3
3 79 Walker, Mike WR 6-2 209 Central Florida Late Round Value
4 101 Podlesh, Adam P 5-11 202 Maryland # 2 P Late Round Value
4 113 Smith, Brian DE 6-3 239 Missouri Off My Board
5 149 Nwaneri, Uche G 6-3 325 Purdue Late Round Value
5 150 Gattis, Josh FS 6-1 213 Wake Forest # 5 FS Round 3
5 166 Landri, Derek DT 6-2 277 Notre Dame Late Round Value
7 229 Broussard, John WR 6-1 178 San Jose State #25 WR Round 4
7 251 Nkang, Chad ILB 5-11 220 Elon # 9 OLB Round 3
7 252 Carnahan, Andrew OT 6-7 306 Arizona State Off My Board
FA Goode, Brett LS 6-1 244 Off My Board
FA Kiser, Roosevelt WR 5-8 169 Florida A&M Off My Board
FA Pudewell, Anthony TE 6-4 252 Nevada Late Round Value
FA Ricard, Lester QB 6-4 235 Tulane Late Round Value
FA Terry, D. D. RB 6-1 196 San Houston St #14 RB Round 4

 

B-

2007 COLLEGE DRAFT REPORT CARD

by Jay Goldberg

TheJaguars got excellent value on day two with Gattis, Broussard and Nkang, but reached in round 4 for defensive end Smith (who may be tried at outside linebacker) and in round three for Walker.  In terms of college street free agents, the Jags signed one of my favorites in running back D. D. Terry, but the team is already deep at running back.

Nelson is a playmaking free safety who should start for the Jags from day one.  Long term (post-Darius) he could pair up with Gerald Sensabaugh to form a hard hitting and extremely athletic pair of safeties.  Nelson was a good get by Jacksonville.  Durant was another good pick.  He is a strong, fast, quick and athletic linebacker who will help on special teams immediately and be Mike Peterson's replacement down the line.  Durant hits like a truck.  Jacksonville has a higher opinion on Mike Walker than me.  He does possess good strength and speed and was productive at Central Florida.  While he is fast he is not overly quick and, therefore,  is more of an outside receiver than a slot receiver.  Don't get me wrong, Walker is a legitimate NFL prospect, just one I thought was a day two value and one more likely to be a #4 receiver than a starter.  I would have gone defensive end Charles Johnson here, and grabbed Allison or Clowney in round four.  Podlesh was one of the better punters in the draft and should win Jacksonville's punting job.  Brian Smith is another player where I have different opinion of value from Jacksonville.  Smith is an undersized pass rushing defensive end who will most likely have to make the transition to outside linebacker in the NFL.  I'm not sure how that will work out so I had Smith off my board.  Nwaneri is better on the field than in the gym.  He is a smart player who can find a home in the NFL as a reliable reserve.  I had a third round grade on Gattis so obviously I thought he was excellent value for Jacksonville in round five.  If I had to guess one of the scenarios the Jaguars looked at if Nelson was off the board was to go with a different position in round one and grab Gattis as to compete for the starting free safety job in round three or four.  With him still on the board in round five they couldn't pass on him.  Gattis, an athletic, fast, playmaking safety, gives the Jags three good young safeties.  If he improves his tackling he could push Sensabaugh as the strong safety of the future.  For now he'll backup Nelson at free safety.  Landri isn't as big as the Jacksonville's starting defensive tackles, but is a hard worker who knows his assignments.  He will be a solid backup for Jacksonville and could see the field spelling the starters this year.  Broussard was another excellent get by Jacksonville.  I had a fourth round grade on this big-play receiver.  Broussard is probably a year or two away from playing a significant role on offense, but has the speed, quickness, and athleticism to develop into a dangerous NFL receiver.  I like Broussard's long term potential better than Walker's long term potential.  Nkang is another player the Jags stole late in the draft.  I had a third round grade on himj because, although he is small, he is a very fast and highly athletic kid who makes plays all over the field.  He is also strong for his size, a sure tackler, and a hard hitter.  I thought he fit best in a defense that relied on speed over size and it remains to be seen if he will ever fit into Jacksonville's scheme, but in the meantime the Jag's got a special teams terror.   Carnahan is a big, strong offensive tackle who needs work on technique because he is limited athletically.  He will probably land on the Jag's development squad.

The Jaguars college street free agents of note include, Goode who is a long snapper and Kiser who is a return man.  Both will have to earn their way onto the Jaguars' roster through special teams play.  Pudewell is a good blocking tight end with poor speed, below average quickness, but good hands.  He could stick as an extra tight end who plays in short yardage and goal line packages.  Ricard is a big, strong-armed quarterback who needs work on his accuracy.  He could land on Jacksonville's development squad.  D. D. Terry was one of the best college street free agents available.  A recent convert to running back from linebacker, Terry runs with a mean streak.  He also has 4.4 speed and is a good receiver.  Unfortunately for him, he choose to sign with a team deep at running back.  However, he could fill the roles of both Toefield and Pearman, thus saving Jacksonville a roster spot.  The backup running back battle should be an interesting one to watch in preseason, and I wouldn't be surprised to see the losers making other teams' rosters.

red indicates workout number in top range at position in draft

COMBINE
YES

 

COLLEGE

POS HGHT WGHT BENCH 40 10 20 SHORT
SHUTTLE
LONG
SHUTTLE
3
 CONE