2008 DRAFT PICKS 2008 REPORT CARD
followed by workout numbers
2008 TEAM NEEDS
prior to free agency
2007 DRAFT PICKS 2007 REPORT CARD
followed by comments & workout numbers
2007 TEAM NEEDS
prior to free agency
2006 Draft Picks 2006 Draft Report Card 2006 Team Needs
2005 Draft Picks 2005 Draft Report Card 2005 Draft Team News
2004 Draft

2003 Draft

2002 Draft

Click here to load 900 Football Links Home Page

2008 DRAFT PICKS
links go to NFL.com website

Arizona
Rd Sel# Player Pos. Ht. Wt. School Jay's ranking Jay's draft value
1 27 Antoine Cason CB 6'0.2" 191 Arizona #4 CB Round 1
3 69 Jacob Hester FB/RB 5'10.5" 226 LSU   Late Round Value
5 166 Marcus Thomas RB 6'0.2" 213 UTEP   Late Round Value
6 192 DeJuan Tribble CB 5'8.6" 189 Boston Col   Late Round Value
7 234 Corey Clark OT 6'5.3" 313 Texas A&M   Late Round Value
FA   Billy Pittman WR 5'11.1" 189 Texas   Late Round Value/Free Agent
FA   Brian Bonner SS/FS/Ret 5'10.7" 196 TCU   Late Round Value

top

C-

2008 COLLEGE DRAFT REPORT CARD

by Jay Goldberg

After the selection of Cason in round one, I didn't particularly like the Chargers' draft.  They also didn't add any players as college street free agents that made me say, "Wow".

DRAFT PICKS

Cason was an excellent pick in round one.  He has good size and quickness, is a good athlete, has enough speed, a nose for the ball and plays smart.  He will replace Florence as the nickel and, long term, be an upgrade.

Hester is a okay as a backup running back, and okay as a backup fullback.  I believe he was over-drafted in round three.  He is not as good a runner as Turner, and as a fullback, is more of a west coast fullback than a blocking back.  As Chrissie Hynde might say (sing), "Don't Get Me Wrong", he will be a valuable backup, but he will not be able to step in as a full time starter shout LT go down with an injury.  My pick here would have been Tashard Choice.  He is more Michael-Turner-like and could be a good NFL starter.

As a backup running back Thomas is more Jacob Hester than Michael Turner.  He does run hard and could be a good short-yardage and goal-line back.  If I were the Charger GM, I would have drafted Choice in round three and then grabbed defensive tackle Rubin here.  Rubin is a strong kid who I predict will develop into a great run-stuffer.  He would have apprenticed behind Williams and been the Chargers' best option should Williams, a key to their defense, missed any significant time.

Tribble looked intriguing on tape, but had a poor showing during Senior Bowl practices and followed that up with workout numbers that verified why he struggled in the post season.  Tribble does have good ball skills, so free safety could be his best NFL position.

The fact that Corey Clark had a nice workout was not surprising.  He has the rep of not playing up to his athletic ability.  As a seventh round pick he makes a lot of sense since the Chargers' coaching staff  can make a decision on whether or not he is worth developing, and if not, there is no major investment in him if he gets cut.  He has the physical skills, it will be interesting to see if he can be developed.

COLLEGE STREET FREE AGENTS

Pittman was a productive receiver at Texas but may not have the speed or quickness to transfer those skills to the NFL.

Bonner could be a surprise in camp.  He can play the run and the pass and will excel on special teams.  He also is a very good punt returner.  I look for him to grab one of the last spots since he can backup both safety spots and provide relief for Sproles in the return game should LT get injured.  Despite drafting Hester and Thomas, Sproles is the best backup running back on San Diego's roster.

red indicates workout number in top range at position in draft
(blue college name indicates workout #'s include Pro Day numbers)

COMBINE
YES
FIRST NAME SCHOOL HEIGHT WEIGHT BENCH 40 10 20 SHORT LONG 3 CONE VERT BROAD
Cason Antoine ARIZONA 6'0.2" 191 20 4.45 1.51 2.53 4.08 NA 7.07 36" 10'8"
Hester Jacob LSU 5'10.5" 226 23 4.60 1.60 2.67 4.24 NA 6.85 29" 9'3"
Thomas Marcus UTEP 6'0.2" 213 21 4.60 1.60 2.65 NA NA NA 30" 9'8"
Tribble DeJuan BOSTON COL 5'8.6" 189 13 4.59 1.56 2.64 4.19 NA 6.88 34.5" 9'8"
Clark Corey TEXAS A&M 6'5.3" 313 23 5.16 1.77 2.97 4.68 NA 7.47 29" 8'10'
Pittman Billy TEXAS 5'11.1" 189 12 4.71 1.63 2.77 4.40 NA 7.06 32.5" 9'6"
Bonner Brian TCU 5'10.7" 196 17 4.60 1.52 2.62 4.26 NA 7.03 34" 9'6"

2008 NEEDS PRIOR TO DRAFT AND FREE AGENCY

SD          Major Need          Need          Upgrade         Depth Need         Not a Need

QB  Rivers proved himself to be one tough cookie and played his best ball in the playoffs.  Volek is a free agent and will "bolt" only if he can't get an opportunity to start elsewhere (how's that for a play on words, twisting the meaning).  Whitehurst may not be ready to be the primary backup.  So if Volek leaves, an experienced quarterback will probably be added.
RB  LT2 is as good as it gets as starting running back.  However, long time sub Turner is a free agent and he will find a team that will, at least, give him an opportunity to start.  Sproles is explosive, but does not have the size to be an every down back if LT2 gets hurt.  The Chargers need to add a backup for LT2.
WR  Suddenly, the Chargers have an excellent starting tandem at wideout in Chambers and Jackson.  I called Davis a reach on draft day and I stand by that comment.  Between Parker, Davis and Naanee the Chargers could find a reliable #3, but look for them to add a receiver between round 3 and 5 in the draft to compete for that spot.
TE Gates, Manumaleuna and Chandler give comprise a solid unit top to bottom for San Diego.
OL  The Titan's line goes six deep with solid to star players.  However, backup inside (guard and center) are needed, and possibly a fourth tackle.
DL The starters are solid, but a young nose tackle to rotate with, and eventually take over after Williams should be added. 
LB No holes in the starting unit, young reserves with potential sitting in the wings.  A nice unit.
DB The Chargers have an excellent pair of corners.  With Florence likely to leave, however, there are questions regarding Gregory and Gordon as the nickel.  McCree should be replaced by Weddle next year.  Hart is an underrated player who is a solid pro, but a stud strong safety could make this unit the best starting secondary in the league.  At a minimum if McCree is gone, a backup a safety will have to be brought on board.
ST Solid all around unit, kicker, punter, and return man.

top

2007 DRAFT PICKS
links go to NFL.com website

Rd Sel# Player Pos. Ht. Wt. School Jay's Ranking Jay's Draft Value
1 30 Davis, Craig WR 6-1 207 Louisiana State #20 WR Round 4
2 37 Weddle, Eric SS 5-11 200 Utah # 3 SS Round 2
3 96 Waters, Anthony ILB 6-3 245 Clemson # 7 ILB Round 3
4 129 Chandler, Scott TE 6-7 257 Iowa # 6 TE Round 3
5 172 Naanee, Legedu WR 6-2 225 Boise State Late Round Value
7 240 Siler, Brandon ILB 6-2 238 Florida # 4 ILB Round 3
FA Hicks,Jarrett WR 6-3 210 Texas Tech Off My Board
FA Arline, Anthony CB 6-1 195 Baylor #12 CB Round 3
FA Buckley, Eldra RB 5-10 202 Tenn-Chat Late Round Value
FA Battle, Tra FS 5-10 173 Georgia Late Round Value
FA Roach, Nick ILB 6-1 246 Northwestern Late Round Value
FA Robertson, Erik G/C 6-3 312 California Late Round Value
FA Leonard, Louis DT 6-5 322 Fresno State Late Round Value

 

C

2007 COLLEGE DRAFT REPORT CARD

by Jay Goldberg

The Chargers had a different opinion on Davis than me.  I had a fourth round grade on him.  They also gave up an awful lot to grab Weddle, who has tremendous potential, but is no sure thing.  On the plus side they got very good value with Chandler and Siler and signed some interesting college street free agents.

Huh?  I had a fourth round grade on Davis, not because he won't be a good NFL player, but because he is best suited as a #3 receiver, not a starter.  He has good (not great as advertised) speed, and his speed is more straight-line than quick-cutting.  He will be a solid NFL contributor but he will not be a star.  If I was going to roll the dice on a speed receiver in round one I would have drafted Jason Hill.  Gonzalez and Smith, drafted after Davis, will be better all around NFL receivers, and I had Clowney as a higher rated speed receiver because of a greater upside.  Weddle could develop into an excellent strong safety.  He better after what the Chargers gave up to get him (including a #3 next year).  Weddle has surprising speed and quickness and is a playmaker but will need to hit the weight room to be more of a force in the box.  Waters may need another year to fully recover from his knee injury, but should provide a solid backup to Wilhelm (who I predict will have a monster year) in time.  He is very good against the run.  Chandler was a great get in round four.  This kid is an excellent receiver.  He has reliable hands, has good quickness, and is sneaky fast.  Unfortunately, with Gates ahead of him, his chances will be limited.  Naanee is a former quarterback who should be a terror on special teams.  He is very strong, fast and athletic.  In time he could be a valuable member of the team because in addition to special teams he has upside as a receiver and, as a former quarterback, can be used in special plays.  I knew I liked Siler more than most, but I didn't think he would fall to round seven.  The Chargers got a steal.  He was a team leader who made tackles and even a few sacks.  However, he is not a particularly good athlete so he may have limited utility on special teams which is most likely why he fell.  I predict he should settle in nicely as Cooper's backup.

The Chargers have a number of college street free agents worth tracking.  Hicks has good size, good hands, and good change-of-direction skills.  He could stick as a special teams player and bottom of the roster player.  He is not an ideal development squad player because what you see is what you're going to get.  His lack of speed limits his upside.  Arline was one of the better college street free agent signings.  He was very good in college showing superb man-to-man cover skills and a nose for the ball.  He does lack quickness so he is best suited to cover a teams' larger outside receiver (he is 6'1") rather than coming in to cover slot receivers.  I look for him to make the Chargers roster or development squad and to be a contributor on defense by next year at the latest (if he is not plucked off their development squad by a team that needs a corner during the season).  Buckley is a surprisingly effective runner who will need to improve his receiving ability to stick.  He could work on that skill on the Chargers' development squad.  Battle could surprise.  He has very good quickness and athleticism and enough speed to be a backup defensive back.  He likes to hit but will need to add bulk and strength to be effective in that role in the NFL.  If Battle can bulk up he could be a versatile sub because he can cover okay as a corner and hit enough for a safety and special teams player.  Look for Battle to be given a year to mature physically on the Chargers' development squad.  Roach, like Waters, is coming back from an injury (broken leg), and like Waters, Roach was a productive player when healthy.  Roach was a tackle hound in college.  Robertson is a tough kid who knows his assignments and is very consistent.  However, he lacks athleticism.  He has a shot to stick as a backup offensive lineman because he can play guard or center and because the coaching staff will know exactly what they're getting if he has to fill in because of injury (which is a plus when calling plays).

red indicates workout number in top range at position in draft

COMBINE
YES

 

COLLEGE

POS HGHT WGHT BENCH 40 10 20 SHORT
SHUTTLE
LONG
SHUTTLE
3
 CONE
VERTICAL
JUMP
BROAD
JUMP
DAVIS CRAIG LSU WR 6'1.1" 200   4.41 1.49  2.54       10'1"  
Davis has good straight-line speed but his quickness and sharp-cutting ability is just average as witnesses by the fact that he was an okay, but not dynamic punt returner.   While he also has reliable hands he didn't separate himself from the pack during the post-season.  He has the look of a long-term solid third wideout.

COMBINE
YES

 

COLLEGE

POS HGHT WGHT BENCH 40 10 20 SHORT
SHUTTLE
LONG
SHUTTLE
3
 CONE
VERTICAL
JUMP
BROAD
JUMP
WEDDLE ERIC UTAH SS/CB 5'11.2" 203 11 4.48 1.43 2.56 4.12