|
|
CLEVELAND BROWNS
Pro
Sports Daily
Official
Site
USA
Today
Pro
Football Weekly
Browns Stats
ESPN
2009
draft 2008
draft 2007 draft
2006 draft
2005
draft 2004
draft 2003
draft 2002
draft
2009
DRAFT PICKS
links go to
NFL.com website
| Rd |
Sel# |
Player |
Pos. |
School |
Jay's
ranking |
Jay's
draft value |
| 1 |
21 |
Alex
Mack |
OC |
California |
#2
OC |
Round
2 |
| 2 |
36 |
Brian
Robiskie |
WR |
Ohio
State |
#8
WR |
Round
2 |
|
Senior
Bowl practice comment |
Robiskie
came on strong as the week progressed. He showed good
moves and hands. He looked very reliable and dependable
but did not make big plays. |
| 2 |
50 |
Mohamed
Massaquoi |
WR |
Georgia |
#9
WR |
Round
2 |
|
Senior
Bowl practice comment |
Massaquoi
was a highlight film including a great catch against tough
coverage; did have one drop but all in all looked very good
while he was there (injured). |
|
Player
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher than
him. |
Massaquoi
came into Senior Bowl practices with a rep for being
inconsistent catching the ball. However, before leaving
with an injury, Massaquoi was a highlight reel of exception
catches. He showed the separation and hands to be a very
good NFL receiver, and that is exactly what I expect him to be. |
| 2 |
52 |
David
Veikune |
DE |
Hawaii |
#8
DE |
Round
2 |
|
Senior
Bowl practice comment |
| Veikune
caught my attention big time. He looked like an
extremely good pass rusher. |
|
ONE
ON ONE BLOCKING DRILLS SCORED BY JAY GOLDBERG |
| 6
- 4 |
Oher
2-2 Johnson 1-1 Kropog
2-0 Watkins 1-1 |
|
|
Player
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher than
him. |
Veikune
really jumped out during Senior Bowl practices. He
was a pass rushing demon. Of the many hybrid speed rushers
in this class, I believe Veikune is one who can keep his hand in
the dirt (rather than converting to 3-4 outside linebacker) and
eventually be a three down defensive end in the NFL.
Although a bit small for a defensive end, the kid is very, very
strong. |
| 4 |
104 |
Kaluka
Maiava |
LB |
Southern
Cal |
#15
OLB |
Round
5 |
| 6 |
177 |
Don
Carey |
CB |
Norfolk
State |
NR |
Late
Round Value |
| 6 |
191 |
Coye
Francies |
CB |
San
Jose State |
#17
CB |
Round
4 |
|
Senior
Bowl practice comment |
| Francies
had some good moments in coverage, including press
coverage. He also played physically and had a big
hit in 11 on 11's. |
|
| 6 |
195 |
James
Davis |
RB |
Clemson |
#19
RB |
Round
5 |
|
Senior
Bowl practice comment |
| Not
a great week for Davis, but data was limited. He
did not show consistent hands catching the ball and did
not stand out in blitz pickup. |
|
ONE
ON ONE BLOCKING DRILLS SCORED BY JAY GOLDBERG |
| 1
- 4 |
Fokou
1-2 Maualuga 0-2 |
|
| FA |
---- |
Phillip
Hunt |
LB |
Houston |
NR |
Late
Round Value |
| FA |
---- |
Nate
Ness |
FS |
Arizona |
NR |
Late
Round Value |
| FA |
---- |
Jordan
Norwood |
WR |
Penn
State |
#26
WR |
Round
5 |
|
C+
|
2009
COLLEGE DRAFT REPORT CARD
|
by
Jay Goldberg
|
|
I
liked the Browns trade with the Jets. The player they
selected with the second round pick, Veikune will be a very
good NFL player. Their trade with the Bucs was also
fine because it was a "no harm no foul"
trade. However, I would have stayed at 19 and drafted
a player other than Mack. I also think the Browns not
selecting a running back higher than round six will come
back to haunt them.
DRAFT
PICKS
As
previously mentioned I would have stopped trading at
#19. That way the Browns could have drafted Macklin
and followed up with a center a the top of round two.
As it is the Browns selected my #2 rated center, however his
grade was close to Eric Wood's grade. While I disagree
with their strategy, Mack will be a solid starting center
for a long time in the NFL.
Given
the selection of Mack, Robiskie was a good pick at the top
of round two. Robiskie is NFL_ready. He will be
a reliable target, but is not a big-play guy. However,
if the Browns selected Macklin in round one, it is very
possible that Mack would have still been on the board for
them here. The Bills took Wood, and it's quite
possible they had him as their #1 center like me.
However if Mack was off the board, Wood or even Unger would
have been fine here.
Massaquoi
is an interesting player. He was on my list of players
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher
than him in the draft. He had a rep coming into Senior
Bowl practices of dropping balls on occasion. However,
he was a highlight reel of terrific catches in practice
before getting injured. While Robiskie is lower
ceiling, low floor; Massaquoi is high ceiling, higher
floor. Based on my grade, you know I believe Massaquoi
will grow into a playmaker in the NFL. This, however,
brings up another point. If the Browns stayed at #19,
they could have drafted Wells or Donald Brown and gone with
just Massaquoi at receiver in round two. Oh
well, we'll see if these missed opportunities come back to
haunt the Browns.
Veikune
was a great pick by Cleveland. He will be one of the
steals of this draft. He will give the Browns a pass
rushing force at outside linebacker. The kid has a
non-stop motor, is very strong, very smart, and has good
pass rushing moves. Being in a position to grab
Veikune was one of the best outcomes of the Browns' trade
with the Jets.
Maiava
will play inside in the Browns' 3-4 defense and he could be
a solid player there. While he has a chance to grow
into a starter, I would have drafted running back Javon
Ringer here. I believe the kid will be a very good NFL
running back. I don't believe I am the only person who
feels that Lewis is not that far away from becoming a three
yards and a cloud of dust back. Ringer would have been
a good long term answer at running back for Cleveland.
Certainly if not Ringer, the Browns would have been better
served here drafting tight end Shawn Nelson.
Carey
was drafted where I thought he would go, however, there were
some corners I had a much better grades on available
here. For taller corners I had Mickens and Trent with
higher grades. I clearly would have tabbed one of
those two over Carey.
Francies
fell because of poor workout numbers. However, he has
good skills, better in fact than Carey. Drafting him
and Carey is like the Browns saying, "I'm not sure, you
two fight it out so I can see who is better".
While in round six that's okay, with Mickens taken in
Carey's spot I would have been confident to go in another
direction here, maybe with TE Cameron Morrah.
With
the pick that I never would have accumulated, the Browns
took running back James Davis, a back I do not believe
offers more than a being a decent backup. As a backup
I would have gone with Javarris Williams over Davis.
Also, this could have been a spot to roll the dice on
Bernard Scott, a very talented kid, one who could be a star,
but a kid with lots of off thee field issues, including
multiple run-ins with the law.
COLLEGE
STREET FREE AGENTS
Hunt
has the athletic ability and quickness to warrant a look at
OLB in the Browns' 3-4 defense. He could be a good
player to develop on the practice squad. I
expect Ness to fight and possibly land a spot on the Browns'
roster. The kid is strong, has good speed, exceptional
quickness and cutting ability and will be a good special
teams player. He could develop into a contributor on
defense down the line as well. Norwood
was the Browns best college street free agent signing.
He has tremendous hands. His measureables are not
great but they are good enough. He reminds me a bit of
the kid Bess on the Dolphins. |
For
chart below: red indicates workout number in top range at position in
draft
ARM-HAND
relative to position, for ranges see ranking pages for 2009 draft
LAST
NAME
at Combine |
FIRST
NAME |
SCHOOL |
HGT |
WGT |
ARM-
HAND |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT |
LONG |
3
CONE |
VERT |
BROAD |
| Mack |
Alex |
California |
6'3.7" |
311 |
M-XL |
20 |
5.17 |
1.75 |
2.96 |
4.75 |
- |
7.31 |
28.5" |
8'10" |
| Robiskie |
Brian |
Ohio
State |
6'2.7" |
209 |
S-L |
- |
4.49 |
1.50 |
2.57 |
4.19 |
- |
6.72 |
37.5" |
- |
| Massaquoi |
Mohamad |
Georgia |
6'1.4" |
210 |
L-L |
- |
4.51 |
1.59 |
2.67 |
4.15 |
- |
7.07 |
36.5" |
10'7" |
| Veikune |
David |
Hawaii |
6'2.3" |
257 |
M-L |
35 |
4.75 |
1.58 |
2.81 |
4.46 |
- |
7.20 |
33" |
9'2" |
| Maiava |
Kaluka |
USC |
5'11.4" |
229 |
S-L |
30 |
4.68 |
1.56 |
2.71 |
4.20 |
- |
6.98 |
- |
9'2" |
| Carey |
Don |
Norfolk
State |
5'11.2" |
192 |
M-L |
18 |
4.48 |
1.47 |
2.59 |
4.20 |
- |
6.87 |
32.5" |
10'2" |
| Francies |
Coye |
San
Jose State |
6'0.3" |
185 |
L-M |
24 |
4.56 |
1.53 |
2.60 |
4.24 |
- |
6.81 |
36" |
10'3" |
| Davis |
James |
Clemson |
5'11" |
218 |
S-XL |
17 |
4.45 |
1.50 |
2.55 |
4.37 |
- |
7.15 |
32" |
9'1" |
| Hunt |
Phillip |
Houston |
6'0.5" |
244 |
- |
14 |
4.75 |
1.60 |
2.71 |
4.22 |
- |
6.91 |
41.5" |
9'8" |
| Ness |
Nate |
Arizona |
6'0" |
193 |
- |
17 |
4.46 |
1.53 |
2.57 |
4.16 |
- |
6.63 |
36" |
10'3" |
| Norwood |
Jordan |
Penn
State |
5'10.7" |
179 |
S-S |
- |
4.57 |
1.57 |
2.63 |
4.18 |
- |
6.80 |
38" |
10'0" |
2009 NEEDS PRIOR TO DRAFT AND FREE
AGENCY
Major need
Need
Upgrade possible
Depth/possible need
Not a need
| QB |
The Browns need to decide
between Anderson and Quinn and stick with the player they choose
and deal the other. The the team needs to secure a good
backup. |
| RB |
I'm not sure Lewis has
much left in his tank. Harrison is a player I liked in the
draft, has shown big-play ability when given a chance, but
hasn't been used enough. Look for that to change this
year. Wright is an UFA. The Browns need a between
the tackle-type to pair with Harrison and cut Lewis. Lewis
is a player you need to feed the ball a lot so he can be
effective in the fourth quarter. I'd rather use a player
who can be spotted with Harrison and still be effective in the
fourth quarter. |
| WR |
Edwards has mad skills
but drops too many balls. Stallworth has mad speed but is
too often on the sideline with injuries or playing with injuries
negating his speed. Jurevicius is a tough kid, gets
injured, vows to play the following year, but then too often
gets injured again. Of their backups, Cribbs is a good
gadget guy and return man and Hubbard is an intriguing prospect.
Still the Browns need a more reliable and productive receiving
corps. |
| TE |
Winslow is a good player
despite his fall off in production last year. However, he
now wants more money and is quickly becoming one of those
players who may be more trouble than he's worth. Rucker
was a nice college player who I does not have the speed to be
anything more than a very average tight end (at best) in the
NFL. |
| OL |
This line is better than
they showed in 2008. The pieces are there, and with the
other needs on this team, I would roll the dice that they can
improve on their 2008 play. |
| DL |
Outside of Rogers this
unit is very pedestrian. Williams did not adapt to the 3-4
as hoped and S. Smith took a step back. Hopefully R. Smith
will come back from injury and help the problem at end some.
I like Rubin's potential at nose, and Thomas and Leonard held
their own when called upon at end. |
| LB |
McGinest and Davis are
UFA's and I'll be very surprised if either is starting for the
Browns next year. Williams is on hand to step in for Davis
and play along side Jackson, who is a very good player.
Wimbley has been a disappointment. He was suppose to be
getting close to double-digit sacks annually by now but hasn't
come close the last two years. This team needs a backup
inside linebacker and at least one new starter outside. |
| DB |
McDonald and Wright are
two young corners who have showed promise but also looked bad at
times. The jury is still out. Holly is sneaky good
at nickel but is an UFA, as is starting strong safety Jones.
Free safety Pool is another player who has had his ups and downs
but may be ready to put it all together. Lawson is a young
player to keep an eye on. He made the tem as a college
street free agent and is a player who was on my list of
underrated prospect. |
2008
DRAFT PICKS
links go to
NFL.com website
| Rd |
Sel# |
Player |
Pos. |
Ht. |
Wt. |
School |
Jay's ranking |
Jay's draft value |
| 4 |
105 |
Beau
Bell |
ILB/OLB |
6'1.2" |
244 |
UNLV |
|
Late Round Value |
| 4 |
111 |
Martin
Rucker |
TE |
6'4" |
251 |
Missouri |
#12 TE |
Round 4/Round 5 |
| 6 |
190 |
Ahtyba
Rubin |
DT |
6'2.6" |
315 |
Iowa State |
#6 DT |
Round 2/Round 3 |
|
Player
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher
than him.
|
Rubin
was unblockable during Senior Bowl drills and followed that up
with a very good game. He can play inside in a 4-3 and
also could play the nose in a 3-4. He is a strong kid
who is a good athlete for a nose tackle. I expect Rubin
to grow into a top run-stuffing tackle who can also push the
pocket and get pressure on the quarterback up the middle.
Rubin is an underrated prospect heading into the draft. |
| 6 |
191 |
Paul
Hubbard |
WR |
6'2.6" |
221 |
Wisconsin |
#16 WR |
Round 3/Round 4 |
|
Player
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher
than him.
|
Want
a sleeper who could be available on day two, but turn into a
solid NFL starter? How about Hubbard. He only
played 8 games his senior year but has an excellent
combination of size, speed, quickness, and athleticism.
He needs better concentration to become a more reliable
target, but has shown good hands in long spurts. He also
comes from a school that has produced NFL receivers like Chris
Chambers and Lee Evans. If drafted in the right
situation (one where he has a chance to see the field),
Hubbard could be a pleasant surprise. |
| 7 |
231 |
Alex
Hall |
DE/OLB |
6'4.6" |
238 |
St Augustine |
|
Free Agent |
| FA |
|
Kolomona Kapanui |
TE |
6'3.3" |
271 |
W Texas A&M |
|
Late Round
Value/Free Agent |
| FA |
|
Eric Young |
OG/OT |
6'3" |
310 |
Tennessee |
#4 OG |
Round 3 |
| FA |
|
Gerald Lawson |
CB/S/RET |
5'10.3" |
192 |
Oregon St |
#21 CB |
Round 4/Round 5 |
|
Player
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher
than him.
|
I
may be one of the only draft sites touting this kid, but I
believe he will make a team and immediately be one of the best
special teams players in the league. Lawton can return
punts and kicks, is a terror on special teams coverage units,
and even blocked a kick in his senior year. As a
defensive back, he could become a valuable dime back because
of his mix of good speed and tremendous athleticism. |
| FA |
|
Darnell Terrell |
CB/FS |
6'1.6" |
203 |
Missouri |
|
Late Round Value |
| FA |
|
Lance Leggett |
WR |
6'3.1" |
194 |
Miami |
|
Late Round
Value/Free Agent |
| FA |
|
Chase Ortiz |
DE/OLB |
6'2" |
249 |
TCU |
|
Late Round
Value/Free Agent |
|
The
Browns did a tremendous job considering their prior trades
which left them without a pick in the first three rounds.
Down the line Rubin and Hubbard could become high-quality
starters. In addition, free agent Eric Young could also
develop into a quality starter when he recovers from injury.
They took care of their major needs in free agency.
However, I still believe they need better insurance for
running back Jamal Lewis than Jason Wright.
DRAFT
PICKS
Bells'
best chance to succeed in the NFL is as a 3-4 inside
linebacker. He can take on blockers and make tackles but
lacks speed, quickness and athleticism. I do not believe
he will ever grow into a starter. My selection at this
spot in the draft would have been running back Tashard Choice.
Rucker
is a good receiving tight end who will be a reliable,
move-the-chains type of player. He is not currently a
good blocker, and will not stretch the field.
The
Browns stole Rubin. In time, he will be a run-stuffing
stud who can also push the pocket against the pass. This
kid was a load to block during Senior Bowl practices. He
is very strong, and a decent athlete for a 315-pound defensive
tackle.
Hubbard
is a very intriguing prospect. He has good size and
speed, and is a top athlete. He has had stretches where
he caught everything, but also has had stretches with drops.
He needs better concentration to become more consistent, but
could develop into an excellent number two receiver in a
couple of years.
Alex
Hall was not on my radar. He is a defensive
end/linebacker tweener who could develop down the line into a
3-4 pass rushing outside linebacker. He looks to be
ticketed for the practice squad.
COLLEGE
STREET FREE AGENTS
Kapanui
is a big kid who has good hands and could develop into a #3
tight end who can block and be a goal line target.
Young
was a great get in free agency. He will probably start
on the PUP and be transferred to injured reserve down the
line, but should compete for a backup spot in 2009. He
has the base skill set to develop into a starter down the
line.
Lawson
is a player I like a lot. Look for him to steal one of
the Browns' last roster spots, and become a terror on special
teams. He will then inch his way into the dime defense.
And if Cribbs gets hurt, he could be a good fill in as a
return man. Lawson likes to hit, is a heady
player, has good speed, and is an explosive athlete.
Terrell
is another option as an extra defensive back. He has
good size and good speed.
Leggett
is a tall receiver who is more fast than quick, but has good
change of direction skills. He could be stashed on the
Browns' practice squad for a couple of years.
Ortiz
is another defensive end/outside linebacker tweener. He
lacks speed and athleticism, but is quick. He could
battle Hall for a spot on the practice squad.
|
red
indicates workout number in top range at position in draft
(blue
college name indicates workout #'s include Pro Day numbers)
COMBINE
YES |
FIRST
NAME |
SCHOOL |
HEIGHT |
WEIGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT |
LONG |
3
CONE |
VERT |
BROAD |
| Bell |
Beau |
UNLV |
6'1.2" |
242 |
25 |
4.90 |
1.72 |
2.83 |
4.56 |
NA |
7.37 |
28.5" |
9'1" |
| Rucker |
Martin |
MISSOURI |
6'4" |
251 |
20 |
4.71 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
| Rubin |
Ahtyba |
IOWA
STATE |
6'2.6" |
315 |
35 |
5.20 |
1.74 |
2.96 |
5.00 |
NA |
8.05 |
28" |
8'10" |
| Hubbard |
Paul |
WISCONSIN |
6'2.6" |
221 |
15 |
4.38 |
1.53 |
2.56 |
NA |
NA |
6.93 |
39.5" |
10'6" |
| Hall |
Alex |
ST
AUGUSTINE |
6'4.6" |
238 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
| Kapanui |
Kolomona |
W
TEXAS A&M |
6'3.3" |
271 |
23 |
5.04 |
1.75 |
2.91 |
4.66 |
NA |
7.42 |
26.5" |
8'11" |
| Young |
Eric |
TENNESSEE |
6'3" |
310 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
| Lawson |
Gerald |
OREGON
ST |
5'10.3" |
192 |
14 |
4.47 |
NA |
NA |
4.28 |
NA |
7.03 |
40.5" |
10'8" |
|
Terrell
|
Darnell |
MISSOURI |
6'1.6" |
203 |
15 |
4.46 |
1.50 |
2.59 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
34" |
10'5" |
| Leggett |
Lance |
MIAMI |
6'3.1" |
194 |
NA |
4.43 |
1.54 |
2.56 |
4.32 |
NA |
6.56 |
NA |
10'4" |
| Ortiz |
Chase |
TCU |
6'2" |
249 |
24 |
4.87 |
1.62 |
2.77 |
4.23 |
NA |
7.03 |
31" |
9'0" |
2008 NEEDS
PRIOR TO DRAFT AND FREE AGENCY
CLE
Major
Need Need
Upgrade Depth
Need Not
a Need
| QB |
Anderson
had a breakout year and the Browns also have last year's #1
pick Quinn. Only an arm for camp will be needed unless
Anderson is moved. |
| RB |
Lewis
had a very good year, which was a surprise for me.
However, he is a free agent. Neither Wright nor Harrison
will be able to step in as a starter should Lewis leave.
So the Browns have to re-sign Lewis, or bring in new starter. |
| WR |
Edwards
is a stud. Jurevicius is an excellent possession
receiver but he has had trouble staying on the field at times
during his career. The bench has no one of particular
interest. The Browns need two receivers. |
| TE |
Winslow
is a top starter, Heiden a top sub who would fill in well if
Winslow went down. Dinkins isn't a bad #3. |
| OL |
The
Browns line played very well in 2007. If Bentley comes
back that will be a bonus and add to this deep unit. If
McKinney leaves in free agency a guard could be brought in to
fight for a roster spot. |
| DL |
Roye
is in decline. Robaire Smith is solid, but not great.
Rookie Shaun Smith was a surprise, but may be better as a
backup who can rotate in at nose and end. The Browns
need to bring in a starter, it could be a nose tackle with S
Smith kicking out to end if needed or an end. It's
possible they will bring in two new starters. Depth is
also a need. |
| LB |
This
s a tough unit to analyze. On the surface, it looks
strong. Jackson and Davis are solid players, but can be
pushed around by big lineman. Williams has shown promise
inside, but needs to be more consistent. On the outside,
McGinest is aging, and Wimbley's sack dropped significantly.
I also keep waiting for McMillan to step up. He's a
player I thought fit perfectly into this defense. My
best guess is that the Browns will bring in a player or two
compete for jobs, but I could also see them going after a stud
to give their defense an identity. |
| DB |
The
Browns' are heading in the right direction in their secondary.
Pool and Jones are a pair of good young safeties. Bodden
and Wright, had good and bad moments, but showed enough to be
counted on in 2008. McDonald also had his good moments
at corner. The Browns will bring in a top corner if one
falls into their lap, but most likely will just bring in
players to compete for backup spots. |
| ST |
The
only reason this spot was not graded as "no need" is
because punter Zastudil had a down year. The Browns will
bring in a punter to push him in camp, but will, most likely,
count on a bounce-back year. Oh yeah, Cribbs is a
special special teams player. |
2007
DRAFT PICKS
links go to
NFL.com website
| Rd |
Sel# |
Player |
Pos. |
Ht. |
Wt. |
School |
Jay's ranking |
Jay's draft value |
| 1 |
3 |
Thomas,
Joe |
OT |
6-6 |
313 |
Wisconsin |
# 1 OT |
Round 1 |
| 1 |
22 |
Quinn,
Brady |
QB |
6-3 |
226 |
Notre
Dame |
# 2 QB |
Round 1 |
| 2 |
53 |
Wright,
Eric |
CB |
5-11 |
190 |
Nevada-Las
Vegas |
# 8 CB |
Round 2 |
| 5 |
140 |
McDonald,
Brandon |
CB |
5-11 |
181 |
Memphis |
# 21 CB, #9 FS |
Round 4 |
| 6 |
200 |
Purcell,
Melila |
DE |
6-5 |
289 |
Hawaii |
|
Late Round Value |
| 7 |
213 |
Pittman,
Chase |
DE |
6-5 |
273 |
Louisiana
State |
|
Late Round Value |
| 7 |
234 |
Steptoe,
Syndric |
WR |
5-9 |
194 |
Arizona |
|
Late Round Value |
| FA |
|
Alston, Mike |
OLB |
6-2 |
231 |
Toledo |
|
Off My Board |
| FA |
|
Mason, Mike |
WR |
6-0 |
189 |
Tennessee State |
#17 WR |
Round 4 |
| FA |
|
Pousson, Brent |
C/OT |
6-3 |
305 |
McNeese State |
|
Late Round Value |
| FA |
|
Stephenson, Scott |
C |
6-3 |
297 |
Iowa State |
|
Late Round Value |
|
Everyone
loves the Browns draft. Put me in the good but not great
column. The Browns come out of draft day with a need at
running back and a need for a #2 receiver who can take the heat
off Edwards. The Browns made two trades on day.
Their trade to get into round one was good. Their trade to
get back into round two, after their first trade, backfired
based on how the draft fell.
While
I liked Peterson best for the Browns, they will get absolutely
no argument from me with the Thomas selection. Offensive
line was an area of need for the Browns and they got the best
one in the draft. I would not have traded up for Quinn.
However, when a team likes a first round quarterback, making a
bold move to get that quarterback is the thing for that team to
do. With Frye and Anderson on the roster, it was a first
round QB for the Browns or no QB for the Browns. Quinn
will be an above average starting quarterback in the league.
The jury is out, however, on whether he will be great. In
my humble opinion, the trade up for Wright backfired.
First of all, even disregarding his off-field issues, I had a
second round, not first round grade on Wright. So he went
where I had him graded and I do not view him as a
potential steal where the Browns got him. Second, if the
Browns stayed where they were, they could have grabbed wide
receiver Jason Hill in round three and running back Antonio
Pittman in round four. If the Browns did that, my grade
for their draft would have been A+. Hill and Pittman will
both be very good NFL players, and have big-play abilities.
The Browns could have come out of this draft with their
franchise left tackle, their quarterback of the future, a great
receiving talent to play opposite Edwards, and a running back
who is a faster Thomas Jones. Wright has decent size and
good speed. He is best in press coverage where he can use
his speed and strength because he has only average quickness.
While he will play receivers physically, he does not step up and
make tackles in the running game. He also has character
concerns. McDonald was a nice get in round five. I
had a fourth round grade on him. He played both corner and
safety in college and could be an excellent dime back. He
has plus coverage skills and is a big-time hitter. In time
he could be a solid starting free safety who can play
centerfield, come up and stop the run, and kick out into
coverage when alignments call for it. Purcell could
develop into a rotation player and eventual starter at defensive
end. He has good size and the 3-4 defense fits his skill set.
Pittman's upside is not as high as Purcell, but neither is his
downside. Pittman will be a solid backup, while Purcell
could become a starter or be out of the league in three years.
Steptoe is a smallish receiver with good hands who is more quick
than fast and can return punts and kickoffs. He has shot
if he shows he can play special teams, but will have to fight
for a roster spot.
The
Browns' college street free agents of note include Alston, an
outside sacking linebacker who has the skill set for a 3-4
outside linebacker, but not the size. He could kick inside
and has a chance to stick on the Browns' development squad.
Mason was a great get in free agency. I had a fourth round
grade on this top athlete. Mason has speed, quickness,
strength, and athleticism and can catch. He also returns
kicks. He will need time, but if he doesn't make the
roster he should make the Browns' development squad. I
like Mason's potential more than Steptoe's potential.
Pousson has played center and tackle and his versatility will
help his cause as he fights for a roster spot. Stephenson
is an ideal development prospect. He is fairly new to
center, plays aggressively, and is quick and athletic. He
could develop into a quality backup and even has the base skills
to be a starter down the line.
|
red
indicates workout number in top range at position in draft
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| THOMAS |
JOE |
WISCONSIN |
OT |
6'6.5" |
311 |
28 |
4.92 |
1.75 |
2.87 |
4.88 |
|
7.95 |
33" |
9'2" |
| Thomas
is the top left tackle in the draft and a top five pick in the
draft. He is strong, quick, and athletic and should be a
Pro Bowl talent in the league. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| QUINN |
BRADY |
NOTRE
DAME |
QB
|
6'3.6" |
232 |
24 |
4.73 |
1.62 |
2.75 |
4.22 |
|
6.79 |
36" |
9'7" |
| Quinn
has good size, excellent strength and athleticism and a very
good arm. He is coming into the NFL ready for battle
having played under Charlie Weis at Notre Dame. One
question about Quinn is his accuracy, but he is fine throwing
short and intermediate, and his long ball accuracy will improve
over time. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| WRIGHT |
ERIC |
UNLV |
CB |
5'10.5" |
192 |
16 |
4.36 |
1.48 |
2.55 |
4.23 |
|
6.93 |
36.5" |
10'3" |
| Wright
has good speed and is best playing press coverage. He is a
character risk having left USC after being arrested on suspicion
of rape. He has second round talent, but his character
issues could lead to him falling in the draft. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| MCDONALD |
BRANDON |
MEMPHIS |
CB/FS |
5'10.7" |
187 |
17 |
4.47 |
1.46 |
2.53 |
4.05 |
|
6.91 |
36" |
10'3" |
| McDonald
can play corner or safety. He has the build of a corner
but the skill set of safety. His best year came in his
senior year while playing free safety. McDonald is quick
and likes to hit. He also has plus cover skills. |
|
COMBINE
NO
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| PURCELL |
MELILA |
HAWAII |
DE |
6'4.6" |
289 |
|
5.19 |
1.81 |
3.03 |
4.71 |
|
7.59 |
31" |
8'11" |
| Purcell
fits best as a 3-4 defensive end. He also showed pass rush
skills at the Hula Bowl. Purcell could be a better NFL
player than he was in college if he the light goes on and he
gets coached up. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| PITTMAN |
BENJAMIN |
LSU |
DE |
6'4.5" |
270 |
23 |
5.03 |
1.68 |
2.88 |
4.64 |
|
7.58 |
27.5" |
8'6" |
| Pittman
has good size and can play in either a 3-4 or 4-3 defense.
Pittman is better against the run, but does get the occasional
sack. Pittman has the look of a valuable backup end. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| STEPTOE |
SYNDRIC |
ARIZONA |
WR/KR
|
5'8.5" |
192 |
17 |
4.52 |
|
|
4.17 |
|
7.05 |
36.5" |
10'4" |
| Steptoe
is a small receiver who is more quick than fast which helps him
as a punt return. He has good hands and could catch on as
a backup receiver and return man. |
|
COMBINE
NO
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| ALSTON |
MIKE |
TOLEDO |
OLB |
6'1.5" |
231 |
13 |
4.59 |
1.52 |
2.59 |
4.28 |
|
7.09 |
37" |
9'10" |
| Alston
was All-MAC. He played often in opposing team backfields
getting both sacks and tackles for loss. He has good speed
and athleticism, but will have to get stronger to play in the
NFL. Just a hunch, but he could move inside in a 3-4
defense. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| MASON |
MIKE |
TENNESSEE
ST |
WR/KR
|
5'11.5" |
189 |
22 |
4.31 |
1.50 |
2.57 |
4.08 |
|
6.94 |
39.5" |
10'10" |
| Mason
is a terrific athlete. He is strong, fast, quick, and
athletic. He transferred to Tennessee State from North
Carolina and led his team in receptions despite suffering a knee
injury midseason. He can also return kicks. Mason will
need time but has the skill set to be a #3 receiver and return
man in the NFL. |
|
COMBINE
NO
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| POUSSON |
BRENT |
MCNEESE
ST |
C/OT |
6'2.6" |
305 |
15 |
5.23 |
1.74 |
2.95 |
4.78 |
|
7.84 |
24" |
7'9" |
| Pousson
projects best as a center in the NFL, but he can also fill in at
right tackle. His versatility could help him make a NFL
roster. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| STEPHENSON |
SCOTT |
IOWA
ST |
C |
6'3.2" |
297 |
22 |
5.11 |
1.74 |
2.94 |
4.57 |
|
7.62 |
30" |
8'7" |
| Srephenson
is relatively new to center, having been recruited as a
defensive tackle. He has the skill set to be a NFL center
but needs some further development. He plays offensive
with a defensive player's mind set; he is very agressive. |
2007
TEAM NEEDS PRIOR TO THE DRAFT and FREE AGENCY
major
need
need
depth/possible
need
not a significant need
| QB |
Anderson
and Frye are question marks, although both have showed
promise. At minimum, add a veteran. |
| RB |
I
actually like their #3 and #4 RBs (Harrison, Barclay) better
than their #1 and #2 (Droughns, Wright) |
| WR |
Edwards
looks like a star in the making. A reliable #2 is
needed. |
| TE |
Winslow
and Heiden are an excellent 1-2. |
| OL |
Fraley
and Friedman are UFAs. A starting OT and a solid backup
are needed. |
| DL |
McKinley
is an UFA, Roye is coming off an injury. Washington is
getting up in age. |
| LB |
Solid
and deep unit. I like McMillan, if they don't maybe a
young player to groom behind McGinest. |
| DB |
Russell
and Brown are UFAs. Safety is young and three deep, if
Baxter can stay healthy corner is also set. |
| ST |
Competition
for all should be brought in. PR Northcutt is an UFA. |
2006
DRAFT PICKS
Links go to write-ups at NFL.com
| Cleveland |
| Rd |
Sel# |
Player |
Pos. |
Ht. |
Wt. |
School |
Jay's
ranking |
Jay's
draft value |
| 1 |
13 |
Wimbley,
Kamerion |
DE |
6-3 |
241 |
Florida
State |
#
3 DE, #2 DE/LB hybrid |
Round
1 |
| 2 |
34 |
Jackson,
D'Qwell |
ILB |
6-0 |
229 |
Maryland |
#
1 ILB |
Round
1 |
| 3 |
78 |
Wilson,
Travis |
WR |
6-2 |
213 |
Oklahoma |
#
19 WR |
Round
4 |
| 4 |
110 |
Williams,
Leon |
ILB |
6-3 |
246 |
Miami
(Fla.) |
#
6 ILB |
Round
3 |
| 4 |
112 |
Sowells,
Isaac |
G |
6-3 |
323 |
Indiana |
#
9 OG |
Round
4 |
| 5 |
145 |
Harrison,
Jerome |
RB |
5-9 |
202 |
Washington
State |
#
6 RB |
Round
2 |
| 5 |
152 |
Minter,
DeMario |
CB |
5-11 |
191 |
Georgia |
#
20 CB |
Round
4 |
| 6 |
180 |
Vickers,
Lawrence |
FB |
6-0 |
246 |
Colorado |
#
1 FB |
Round
4 |
| 6 |
181 |
Oshinowo,
Babatunde |
DT |
6-1 |
305 |
Stanford |
#
9 DT |
Round
2 |
| 7 |
222 |
Hamilton,
Justin |
SS |
6-2 |
218 |
Virginia
Tech |
Late
Round Value |
>
Round 4 |
| |
FA |
Hackney,
Darnell |
QB |
6-0 |
239 |
UAB |
#11
QB |
Round
4 |
| |
FA |
Barclay,
Chris |
RB |
5-8 |
180 |
Wake
Forest |
#
15 RB |
Round
4 |
|
The Browns reached slightly in round three,
but got excellent value with Harrison and Oshinowo on day two.
All in all, the Browns did a nice job of drafting for value.
In round one the Browns drafted Wimbley, who
has the athletic ability to play OLB in a 3-4 defense.
While Wimbley will be solid, don't expect him to be a Shawn
Merriman. In fact, if the Browns wanted a pure pass
rushing outside linebacker, Manny Lawson would have been the
better pick. Wimbley will be better all around linebacker
than Lawson, but Lawson will be more of a game-changer.
Either would have been a good selection. Jackson was a
great pick in the second round. While he doesn't have the
ideal bulk for a 3-4 inside linebacker, he is tough kid with
good football skills and can get the occassional sack and
interception as well as being a reliable tackler. Jackson
was my top rated ILB, and I had a first round grade on him.
Wilson was not a bad pick in round three, however, I had a
fourth round grade on him because I think his highest watermark
in the NFL is as a slot receiver, albeit a unique one because he
is 6'2" with the quickness of smaller receivers. On
day one I like teams that draft players with starting potential.
Hagan, Marshall and D Williams were all players who were on the
board who could be effective slot receiver, and have the
potential to be starters down the line. Leon Williams was
a very intriguing selection on round four. Unlike Jackson,
he has the prototypical size desired in 3-4 inside linebackers.
Williams is a terrific athlete who hasn't put it all together on
the field yet, but could be a stud if the Browns' coaching staff
can get his light to go on. Worst case he will be a stud
on special teams. Sowells is a bit of a tweener (and no, I
don't mean the kid from Prison Break). He as the build for
a tackle, but the feet and mentality for a guard. He will
either have to get tougher to play tackle, or add weight to play
guard. However, he could be a reliable reserve.
Jerome Harrison was a steal. After the Bush and the big
four (Williams, Maroney, Addai, White), I had Harrison rated as
the next best back. In fact, his situation reminds me of
Marion Barber last year. I had Barber rated as the best
back after the elite, and based on his rookie campaign I'll
stand by my ranking. If given a chance, Harrison will be
an excellent NFL back. Right now he is being looked at as
a third down, change-of-pace back, but he has the skills to be
quality starter. Harrison is quick, a good athlete, a
tough runner who can be effective between the tackles despite
his size. Minter is a solid day two cornerback. He
will play well in sub-packages and be a quality reserve, but
will probably never be a full time starter. Vickers was my
top rated fullback. He can catch, block, and even be used
as a short-yardage and goal-line runner. Oshinowo was an
another theft by the Browns. He is a very strong kid who
plays low to the ground and can occupy blockers. He is
perfect for the nose in a 3-4 despite being "only" 300
pounds. Hamilton is a versatile athlete who has played
free safety, running back, and wide receiver. He should be
a solid special teams performer but may need to show defensive
back skills to stick.
In terms of college street free agents, the
Browns signed Keith as a free agent but he failed his physical.
He could come back when he gets healthy. He played
defensive end in college but projects to outside linebacker in
the 3-4. Two players signed who did not fail their
physicals were QB Hackney, and RB Barclay. Hackney has a
live arm and NFL-caliber quarterback skills, but at under 6',
will find it tough to stick with the Browns. Barclay
is another undersized prospect. However, as an undersized
running back, I like him more than Drew who drafted in round two
by the Jaguars. Barclay is faster than Drew, quicker than
Drew, stronger than Drew, a better athlete than Drew, and was as
productive a back as there was in the ACC last year.
Unfortunately for him, he signed with a team where he may find
it hard to make the final roster. Harrison could stand in
his way as the change-of-pace, third down back. However,
he could give the Brown fans a lot of excitement late in
exhibition games, and make it very difficult for the coaches to
cut him. Look for the Browns to make it a priority to sign
Barclay to their practice squad if forced to cut him.
|
red indicates
workout number in top range at position in draft
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Wimbley |
Florida
State |
6'3.6",
248 |
4.42 |
1.60 |
2.70 |
4.48 |
|
6.97 |
24 |
38.5" |
10'9" |
|
DE/OLB
Jay Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET -
Wimbley showed terrific quickness and pass rush skills during
Senior Bowl practices.
Jay Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET
- Wimbley has the speed, agility, and athleticism to play OLB in
a 3-4 defense. While some compare him to Ware in lat
year's draft, Wimbley may be a better all around linebacker, but
not as dominating a pass rusher. |
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Jackson |
Maryland |
6'0.4",
230 |
4.70 |
1.64 |
2.79 |
4.37 |
|
7.05 |
19 |
37" |
9'8" |
|
ILB
Jay Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET -
Jackson played very well versus the run at the Senior Bowl.
Jay Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET -
Jackson is the best
inside linebacker in the draft. He is a physical presence
in the middle with excellent instincts and tackling skills.
While he is perfect for a 4-3 middle linebacker, he has the pass
rush skills to be effective inside in a 3-4 despite not having
the optimal size. Jackson had over 250 tackles the last
two years with 6.5 sacks and 4 interceptions. |
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Wilson |
Oklahoma |
6'2",
219 |
4.48 |
1.58 |
2.62 |
3.99 |
11.26 |
6.70 |
|
36.5" |
10'0" |
|
Jay Goldberg,
900FootballLinks.NET - Wilson had some good moments during
Senior Bowl practices, including a nice move and catch on a deep
ball.
Jay Goldberg,
900FootballLinks.NET - Wilson had a disappointing senior season
catching only 25 balls for 310 yards and 1 TD, after catching 50
balls and 11 TDs his junior season. Part of the drop off
was Wilson battling injuries, part was a drop off in talent
around him on offense. However, Wilson has good size and
speed, and excellent quickness. He could develop into a
nice slot receiver. |
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Williams,
L |
Miami |
6'3",
245 |
4.54 |
1.57 |
2.68 |
4.08 |
11.68 |
7.08 |
25 |
34" |
9'9" |
|
ILB
Jay
Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET - Based on Williams athletic
ability, he should be a terror on the football field. In
college, he was solid, but not star. However, he has
excellent size, speed, strength, and quickness, and I'm sure a
team will fall in love with his physical skills and draft him
for his upside. With his inherit skills, I think Williams
has a chance to be a very good player. Worst case, he will
be a force on special teams. |
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Sowells |
Indiana |
6'3.3",
315 |
5.15 |
1.84 |
3.03 |
4.78 |
|
7.58 |
20 |
28.5" |
8'5" |
|
OG/OT
Jay
Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET - Sowells started at left tackle
for Indiana, but lacks toughness and strength, so may have to
move to guard in the NFL. While Sowells is a bit light for
guard, he has good speed and quick feet and the body to add the
necessary weight to play that position in the NFL. Sowells
needs some work, but could be a valuable reserve, with the
potential to start down the road. |
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Harrison |
Wash
State |
5'9.2",
201 |
4.47 |
1.55 |
2.62 |
4.07 |
|
6.77 |
19 |
34.5" |
10'4" |
|
|
PLAYER
WHO WILL PERFORM BETTER IN NFL THAN MANY DRAFTED BEFORE
HIM
|
Harrison
is quick, strong, and faster than many thought.
Harrison accumulated over 2,100 yards rushing and
receiving his senior year. The knock on him is his
lack of size and inside running ability. However,
he has excellent strength for his size, and showed the
ability to run effectively inside at the Senior Bowl.
Harrison will be looked at as a change-of-pace,
third-down back, but will eventually be an every-down
NFL back, and a good one.
|
RB
Jay Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET - At the Senior Bowl,
Harrison displayed quick feet. Harrison changes direction
very well, is slippery making tacklers miss, and showed the
ability to run inside.
Jay
Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET - Harrison showed excellent
quickness in Combine drills. |
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Minter |
Georgia |
5'11.2",
185 |
4.48 |
1.61 |
2.70 |
4.10 |
11.56 |
6.88 |
10 |
38.5" |
10'11" |
|
CB
Jay
Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET - Minter is a good athlete who
will fit in best for a team that uses primarily zone defenses.
He does not, currently, possess good man-to-man cover skills
because his speed and quickness are only average for the
position. Minter also had issues with marijuana his junior
season. Minter is the type of player who will find a role
on a NFL team as an extra defensive back, but may never be of
starting caliber. |
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Vickers |
Colorado
St |
6'0.2",
245 |
4.76 |
1.74 |
2.88 |
4.64 |
|
7.75 |
21 |
31.5" |
8'8" |
|
Jay Goldberg,
900FootballLinks.NET - Vickers, a FB, had a nice week of
practice at the Senior Bowl.
Mike Mayock
- Vickers caught the ball very well at the Combine.
Jay
Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET - Vickers is one of the
best fullbacks in the draft. He can block, he is a food
short-yardage back, and he can catch. |
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Oshinowo |
Stanford |
6'1.4",
304 |
5.25 |
1.80 |
3.04 |
4.57 |
|
7.63 |
33 |
32" |
8'9" |
|
DT/NT
Jay Goldberg,
900FootballLinks.NET - Oshinowo had an impressive week of
practice at the Senior Bowl. He is a player who is better
between the lines than in the workout room.
Jay
Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET - Despite weighing
"only" 300 pounds, Oshinowo is an excellent run
stuffer because he has tremendous strength and plays low to the
ground. A true nose tackle, Oshinowo is a good prospect
for teams that play the 3-4 defense. |
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Hamilton |
Virginia
Tech |
6'2.4",
218 |
4.52 |
|
|
4.04 |
|
6.66 |
19 |
42.5" |
10'6" |
|
FS/WR/RB - NOT AT COMBINE
Jay Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET -
Hamilton moved to defense after playing wide receiver and
running back. He is a gifted athlete and will be a solid
special teams player in the NFL. |
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Hackney |
UAB |
5'11.5",
240 |
4.76 |
1.73 |
2.84 |
4.69 |
|
7.62 |
|
33" |
9'2" |
|
Jay Goldberg,
900FootballLinks.NET - At the Senior Bowl appeared to be a
rhythm passer, having moments where his throws were off, and
moments of excellent accuracy. He is a bit too short for
most NFL GMs.
Jay Goldberg,
900FootballLinks.NET - Hackney has good quarterback skills but
they are not good enough to offset his short stature. He showed
improved accuracy his senior year, completing over 60% of his
passes and had about a 2:1 ration of TD passes to interceptions. |
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Barclay |
Wake
Forest |
5'8.3",
180 |
4.35 |
|
|
4.09 |
|
6.65 |
16 |
42" |
10'6" |
|
|
PLAYER
WHO WILL PERFORM BETTER IN NFL THAN MANY DRAFTED BEFORE
HIM
|
Barclay
and Drew are two smaller backs in the draft with very
good college production. The draft
"chatter" has been around Drew, but I like
Barclay better. He is bigger than Drew,
faster than Drew, quicker than Drew, and a better
athlete than Drew. Barclay is flying under the
radar, but will pay dividends to the team that drafts
him.
|
NOT AT COMBINE
Jay Goldberg,
900FootballLinks.NET - Barclay was a very productive college
running back, who is small, but could surprise in the NFL as a
third-down, change-of-pace back. |
2006
TEAM NEEDS
prior to free agency
| CLE |
| QB |
With Frye, Dilfer, and even Anderson,
there is no room at the Inn. The Browns will not
bring in any quarterbacks unless there are injuries. |
| RB |
Droughns is a nice back, but good teams
have backs that are great, not nice. Suggs is
injury prone, and Green is no more than a backup.
A franchise back is needed, but Droughns can carry the
load until they get one. |
| WR |
Edwards is coming back from injury, and
young receivers usually blossom in year three anyway.
Bryant is an UFA. Northcutt is a good slot
receiver. The Browns will need a reliable starter
if Bryant leaves. |
| TE |
Heiden played well and is a valuable
player as a backup tight end who can be an effective
starter. If Winslow can finally get to the field,
and retain his pre-injuries ability, the position is
set. If not, another tight end is needed. |
| OL |
Shelton is an UFA who the Browns should
try to resign. If they do they can return their
starting unit in tact and have one less unit to worry
about in the offseason. |
| DL |
Only one current starter, Roye is a
player who would start on good teams, but he is an UFA.
The Browns will need at least one starting end (two if
Roye leaves), and a starting nose tackle. |
| LB |
Again, only one starter is a player who
would start on good teams. At least Davis is not
an UFA. The Browns need an inside linebacker to
pair with Davis (Taylor is an UFA who won't be asked
back), one starting outside linebacker, and another
outside backer to challenge Thompson. |
| DB |
Baxter, Boden, and McCutcheon are NFL
starting caliber corners. Young safeties Jones and
Pool could challenge Crocker and Russell for their
starting jobs. The only real need will be if
Baxter has trouble returning from injury. |
| ST |
Cribbs, Northcutt and Dawson are good
at what they do. Richardson is inconsistent.
A player could be brought in to challenge him in camp. |
|
2005
COLLEGE DRAFT
| Cleveland
- links below go to NFL.com reports |
Jaybird |
Jaybird |
| Rd |
Sel# |
Player |
Pos. |
Ht. |
Wt. |
School |
Ranking |
Value Board |
| 1 |
3 |
Edwards,
Braylon |
WR |
6-3 |
211 |
Michigan |
# 1 WR |
Round 1 |
| 2 |
34 |
Pool,
Brodney |
FS |
6-2 |
208 |
Oklahoma |
# 3 FS |
Round 2 |
| 3 |
67 |
Frye,
Charlie |
QB |
6-4 |
217 |
Akron |
# 3 QB |
Round 1 |
| 4 |
103 |
Perkins,
Antonio |
CB |
5-11 |
188 |
Oklahoma |
#18 CB |
Round 4 |
| 5 |
139 |
McMillan,
David |
DE |
6-3 |
246 |
Kansas |
#17 DE |
Round 4 |
| 6 |
176 |
Speegle,
Nick |
OLB |
6-5 |
242 |
New
Mexico |
Late Round Value |
> Round 4 |
| 6 |
203 |
Hoffman,
Andrew |
DT |
6-4 |
296 |
Virginia |
Late Round Value |
> Round 4 |
| 7 |
217 |
Dunn,
Jon |
OT |
6-7 |
328 |
Virginia
Tech |
|
> Round 4 |
| FA |
|
Flowers, Bill |
WR |
6-0 |
188 |
Mississippi |
Late Round Value |
> Round 4 |
| FA |
|
Burt, Larry |
DT |
6-2 |
305 |
Miami, Ohio |
Late Round Value |
> Round 4 |
| FA |
|
Fraser, Simon |
DE |
6-6 |
288 |
Ohio State |
Late Round Value |
> Round 4 |
| FA |
|
King, James |
SS |
6-0 |
212 |
Central Michigan |
Late Round Value |
> Round 4 |
| FA |
|
Scott, Chad |
RB |
5-8 |
199 |
North Carolina |
Late Round Value |
> Round 4 |
| The Browns did not reach for any of their draft
picks, and got excellent value with Frye in the third, and
McMillan in round five.
The Browns had an excellent draft. Edwards gives them
a legitimate number one receiver, something they have been
lacking for years. Northcutt, Davis, and Bryant are all
solid number-two-type receivers. Edwards immediately
upgrades the position from a weak to strong. He has good
size, speed and strength. Many draft analysts will think
Pool was a steal in round two. He wasn't, he went where
I had him graded. In fact, I like Josh Bullocks better
than Pool, who was drafted a few spots after Pool. That
said, Pool will be an above-average free safety in the league
who will fit nicely into Coach Crennel's defense. Now
Frye, he was a steal in round three. Frye will be a
successful starting quarterback in the NFL. He will, in
time, be better than one or more from amongst Smith,
Rodgers, and Campbell, all selected in round one.
Perkins is another good fit for the Browns. He is an
aggressive, confident corner, who has excellent ball skills,
and can return punts. He does lack top speed for a
corner, but should fit nicely into a defense that uses
multiple schemes. McMillon was another great pick for
Crennel's defense. He was a fast, quick athletic college
defensive end. He will be the first college
defensive-end turned NFL linebacker by Crennel to become a
cornerstone in the Browns' defense for years. Mark it
down. Speegle is another interesting prospect. He
had good production at New Mexico, but was thought to be too
slow, and lacking in athletic ability, to translate his
success in college to the NFL. Then he had a very good
workout. While he will start competing at outside
linebacker, Speegle actually showed enough speed and
athletic ability to also play inside. He could be a
versatile backup for the Browns playing different roles in a
variety of defensive packages. Hoffman played nose
tackle in college, but will have to bulk up to stay at there
in the NFL. However, he has the perfect size, and enough
athleticism to be developed as a defensive end in the Browns'
new 3-4. The one pick I have disagree with some was
offensive tackle Joe Dunn in round seven. If it comes
down to the only slight disagreement with a draft being a
seventh round selection, you know I liked that teams draft a
lot. While any player in round seven will need
development, Dunn included, I thought their were tackles with
a higher upside than Dunn still on the board at that spot.
Some included Erik Pears of Colorado State, Kyle Wallace of
Georgia Tech, and even Michael Munoz of Tennessee.
The college street free agent signings by the Browns should
be looked at with tremendous optimism, both for this year, and
years to come. The new regime showed a
"Patriot-like" ability to sign some of the better
potential role players available. A prime example is
wide receiver Bill Flowers. Flowers will never be a
star. However, he is a player who can get open and catch
the ball. He is a perfect fourth or fifth receiver.
Many teams carry extra receivers that may develop into stars.
Smart teams keep players that can contribute at a high level
in their designed role. Flowers is the type of player
smart teams find room for on their roster. Burt went to
the right system for him. He is a cone dimensional
run-stuffer, who could be good as a backup nose tackle.
Again, a solid role player for the Browns' system.
Fraser, like Burt, also found signed with a team where his
value is higher than it would be for teams playing the 4-3.
He is not an effective pass-rusher because he lacks speed.
However, is can play the run, and engage offensive lineman so
linebackers can make tackles. If James King shows any
potential as a strong safety, he will be tough to cut.
He has excellent size, great speed and quickness, and good
strength. He should be a terror on special teams while
he hones his craft. Scott is an interesting case.
He was third string at North Carolina, but got to play in big
spots because of injuries. In his first start, Scott ran
for 175 yards, and he scored two touchdowns against Miami.
He is certainly worth a look in training camp.
|
RED NUMBERS BELOW - among
best at position
Long shuttle numbers (where available) in blue, top performers to be
determined later
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| Edwards |
WR |
4.42 |
|
4.02 |
|
6.83 |
23 |
37.5" |
10'6" |
22 |
Gil
Brandt of NFL.com reports: Edwards was reported
to have a great workout, as Edwards didn't have one drop (note -
GBRepott.com, a very reliable site, had Edwards forty time
faster than NFL.com).
Bob LeGere Daily Herald Sports Writer (www.dailyherald.com)
reports: Michigan
wide receiver Braylon Edwards could wind up as the No. 1 overall
pick in the NFL draft, or he could go to the Bears at No. 4.
Either scenario would require teams to ignore foolish
comparisons between Edwards and the last wide receiver from
Michigan whom the Bears drafted in the first round -
disappointing David Terrell. Edwards doesn't discourage
all of the comparisons, but he draws a distinct line between him
and Terrell, whom he considers a friend. "With the
physical comparisons, I love them," the 6-foot-3, 212-pound
Edwards said. "Dave's a big guy; I'm a big guy. Dave's a
physical guy; I'm physical. Dave made a lot of plays; I make
plays. "But that's as far as it goes. I'm a guy
that's different than Dave. Dave is David Terrell, and I'm
Braylon Edwards. I'm not saying anything negative about Dave
because Dave is a good person. I know him personally, but that's
not me."
Jay Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: The
best receiver in the draft. He has size. He has
speed. He has hands. He will be a big-time player in
the NFL for years to come. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| Pool |
FS |
4.54 |
|
4.50 |
|
7.25 |
|
39" |
10'8" |
16 |
| Jay
Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: Pool
has good, not great skills, and while he will be a solid NFL, is
not a player I would draft in the first round as many are
projecting. He is a solid second round pick. Pool is
the type of player who will be an above-average starter who a
team will be very pleased with, but would consider replacing if
they could get a stud. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| Frye |
QB |
4.87 |
|
4.09 |
|
6.95 |
|
33" |
9'5" |
38 |
|
JAYBIRD
PLAYER WHO WILL HAVE A BETTER NFL CAREER THAN MANY DRAFTED
HIGHER THAN HIM
|
In addition to having above
average quarterback skills, Frye is an excellent leader. In the
long run he will be a good starting quarterback in the NFL.
Between Rodgers and Smith, history indicates one will falter.
Frye won't.
|
Colin
Lindsay of GBNReport.com reports: Any
questions NFL teams had about Akron QB Charlie Frye’s arm
strength may have been put to rest when the former Zips’ star
launched a 60-yard plus pass from a flat-footed position at the
end of a pro workout yesterday in Akron. Indeed, by all
accounts, Frye had an overall solid workout in front of
officials from 11 NFL teams.
Allen Trieu of NFLDraftShowcase.com reports: Frye's
career has been a tough one to judge. He hasn't had the
supporting cast around him that other MAC QBs have had. However,
in terms of physical ability, he has the physical tools needed
to succeed at the next level. However, he needs a great deal of
technical and classroom work and he's at least 2-3 years away
from being able to play. 3rd/4th Round.
Jay Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: Frye
played very well during the Senior Bowl game showing accuracy,
arm strength and good mobility in the pocket. One of my
top six players in the game.
Colin Lindsay of GBNReport.com reports: Charlie
Frye of Akron was not particularly accurate in either
facet (individual drills and 11 on 11 drills) of the practice on
Wednesday at Senior Bowl practice.
Colin Lindsay of GBNReport.com reports:
Akron's Charlie Frye has probably shown the most pro potential
of the North QBs (at Senior Bowl practices). Frye is very
athletic with nimble feet, sets up quickly and gets rid of the
ball in good order. Frye also shows a good, though, not
necessarily great arm and throws a very catchable ball. Frye,
though, tended to lock onto receivers which drew a blast from
Oakland head coach Norv Turner who is heading the North team.
Zac Jackson, of ClevelandBrowns.com, reports: Akron
QB Charlie Frye had a second consecutive good performance during
Senior Bowl practice Tuesday, Jan. 25. Frye has been
consistently accurate with his short throws but has put a little
too much air under a few of his deep balls.
Jay Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET
reports: Love this kid. As good a leader as
quarterback. Has all the intangibles. Isn't too
shabby between the lines either. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| Perkins |
CB |
4.50 |
1.60 |
4.07 |
|
7.18 |
10 |
40" |
10'6" |
20 |
| Jay
Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: Perkins
missed a couple of games last year with a knee injury, so his
numbers could improve as his knee gets stronger. He is a
solid cover corner with good ball skills and very dangerous in
the open field. He is also a solid punt returner. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| McMillon |
DE |
4.60 |
1.60 |
4.08 |
|
7.11 |
16 |
34" |
10'0" |
16 |
|
JAYBIRD
PLAYER WHO WILL HAVE A BETTER NFL CAREER THAN MANY DRAFTED
HIGHER THAN HIM
|
McMillan is a fast, quick,
athletic defensive end who will be a difference maker on third
down. He may never develop into a full time starter, but
McMillian will be a valuable role player for the team that
drafts him.
|
| Jay
Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: McMillan
has to decide whether to bulk up and try to be an end in a
team's rotation, or to keep his weight down and either
play in the nickel or try his hand at outside linebacker.
He certainly has the athletic ability to move to linebacker. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| Speegle |
OLB |
4.50 |
|
4.40 |
|
7.16 |
18 |
38.5" |
10'3" |
|
| Jay
Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: Speegle was
a productive player on the field but was thought to have speed
and athletic ability limitations. His workout, however,
contradicts that notion. He could be good value on day two
of the draft. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| Hoffman |
DT |
5.09 |
|
4.70 |
|
|
20 |
30.5" |
9'2" |
|
| Jay
Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: Hoffman
played nose tackle, but will have to bulk up to play that
position in the NFL. Luckily, he has a large frame so he
should be able to add the weight. he could also slide to
end in a 3-4 defense. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| Dunn |
OT |
5.44 |
1.88 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
18 |
| Jay
Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: Dunn has a
big body, but is slow and needs a lot of work. He has
potential, but a team will have to be patient with him, maybe
very patient. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| Flowers |
WR |
4.50 |
|
|
12.12 |
7.24 |
|
|
|
|
|
JAYBIRD
PLAYER WHO WILL HAVE A BETTER NFL CAREER THAN MANY DRAFTED
HIGHER THAN HIM
|
Looking for a long shot who isn't
even listed in the names at the end of some of the draft guides?
Bill Flowers is a player I like. Why? Because he can get open
and catch the ball. Flowers will not be a star. He may even
bounce around on practice squads for a couple of years. However,
he should finally stick as that fourth or fifth receiver who
comes in and makes the clutch catch. Think Looker in St. Louis.
Why am I mentioning a player who will peak as an extra receiver?
Because, if given a chance (always a risk with a player like
Flowers), he will be around and be a contributor long after many
of the receivers drafted ahead of him are out of the league.
|
Gil Brandt
of NFL.com reprots: Flowers looked impressive
catching the ball during his Pro Day.
Jay Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: Flowers
caught my eye at the Gridiron Classic game. He kept
getting open and catching the ball. He also looked good
going over the middle. Based on this game, Flowers showed
above average hands and moves, although he didn't show run after
the catch ability. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| Burt |
DT |
5.29 |
1.90 |
4.75 |
|
8.03 |
25 |
31" |
8'5" |
12 |
| Jay
Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: Burt didn't
test as well as I thought he would. He did okay, but may
have looked good on the field because of the competition he
faced in college. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| Fraser |
DE |
5.01 |
1.75 |
4.44 |
|
7.57 |
23 |
28" |
8'10" |
29 |
| Jay
Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: Fraser's
best chance on the next level is as a 3-4 defensive end.
He plays the run much better than the pass. He could be
effective engaging offensive lineman so linebackers can run free
and make tackles. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| King |
SS |
4.43 |
|
3.98 |
11.41 |
6.63 |
18 |
|
|
|
| Jay
Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: King showed
a good combination of speed, quickness and strength during his
workout. He also has good size for a strong safety.
He is worth a look in training camp. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER-
LIC |
| Scott |
RB |
4.47 |
|
4.24 |
11.43 |
6.98 |
19 |
32.5" |
9'6" |
|
| Jay
Goldberg of 900FootballLinks.NET reports: Scott was
the third string running back on North Carolina. However,
when called upon due to injuries he performed very well.
Scott rushed for a career high 175 yards in his first start, and
scored two touchdowns against Miami. And he did all this despite
sustaining a hip-pointer in the third quarter that caused a
brief exit. |
2005
TEAM NEEDS PRIOR TO FREE AGENCY AND THE DRAFT
Jay Goldberg of
90FootballLinks.NET reports:
major
need
need
position
possible
need, depth needed
no real need
Key UFA: Garcia QB, Holcombe QB, Cook G, Zukauskas G,
Holdman LB, Henry CB
Key RFA: Fowler C (3rd), Gonzalez OT (7th), Davis LB (5th),
Taylor LB (4th)
NOTE - RFA COMPENSATION AT MINIMUM TENDER
QB:
Garcia will be cut.
Holcombe is an UFA. McCown has some upside, but isn't
ready. Same for Harris. They need a starter for next
year, and maybe a prospect for the future if McCown isn't their
guy.
RB: Suggs
would be fine if he stayed healthy. Green is not a bust,
but will never be a franchise back. Echemandu is
intriguing. He has talent.
WR: Davis,
Bryant and Northcutt are good receivers, but none are feared
number ones. The Browns need to find a true go-to guy.
TE:
Heiden and Shea are
steady. There is no need here unless it is a difference
maker.
OL:
Between lack of talent
and free agents, this is a main area of concern for the Browns.
They could put together a decent line, depending upon who
resigns, but more talent no matter who resigns is needed.
DL:
Lang, Ekuban and Brown
are a decent rotation at end. Unless Warren comes on
big-time, a difference-maker at defensive tackle is needed.
LB:
If Davis is resigned,
that would go a long way towards stabilizing this unit. He
and Holdman are UFAs. Thompson is a young player who will
get better. At least one linebacker will have to be
brought in since it is doubtful both davis and Holdman will
resign.
DB:
Henry and McCutchin
are a solid pair, but neither is a shut-down corner and Henry is
a RFA. Griffith finally had the year they expected when
they signed him as a free agent. Little and Crocker are
decent options at free safety.
ST: Dawson is an underrated kicker. Frost did fine in
his first year as a punter. Northcutt and Alston are good
return-men.
|
2004
COLLEGE DRAFT
| Where's the beef? And I don't mean
Wendy's hamburgers and I don't mean "no agruement".
I mean where's the offensive tackle. Winslow was a fine
selection in the first round, especially with Gallery off the
board. He can be a special player. Let's see if
the Browns use him enough to justify him as the sixth player
in the draft. Sean Jones is a good player who I had
rated as a high-to-mid second round value. McCown is a
good athlete, with the potential to grow into a starter and is
a good fit behind Jeff Garcia. He was also selected
about where I had him graded. Stanford teammates,
Chambers and Gordon both have chances if given time to
develop. Echemandu was an out-and-out steal in round
seven. He fell in the draft because he was injured and
did not heal in time to work out for the scouts. When
healthy, he has third-round ability............. Okay, ask
your question. This doesn't seem like a B- drat.
It appears the Browns did very well. This is where my
initial question comes into play. The Browns should have
taken OT Max Starks in round two and drafted a safety in round
four (Will Allen and Dexter Reid were available) or round five
(Jason Shivers); or drafted Jones and selected OT Nat Dorsey
in the fourth, hoping McCown would fall to them in the fifth
(only one QB came off the board between the Browns' selection
of McCown and their next pick). They needed the beef!
As far as their free agents they signed an interesting talent
in Osunde who can immediately be a pass-rush specialist from a
defensive end position. Osunde's best full-time NFL
position would be as an outside linebacker in a 3-4 defense.
They also signed Geathers, a good athlete who is new to the
receiver position but has the speed and athletic ability to
develop into a player who can be useful in multiple receiver
sets; Buhl, a linebacker in a safety's body who may excel on
special teams; Hickman, a linebaker who has some talent and
may be a good depth-guy; Curry, a free safety who is a good
player but injury-prone; and Grant, a strong safety from
a small school who has the speed and ability to cover wide
receivers but will need time to develop. Grant could be
a major contributor down-the-line. |
PLAYER/
TEAM NEWS PRIOR TO DRAFT
| PLAYER |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
| Winslow
II |
6-3
7/8, 247 |
4.55 |
- |
4.10 |
11.35 |
6.71 |
24 |
33½" |
10-1 |
Winslow
Miami
#1 ranked TE by
Jaybird
|
Pete
Fiutak / CollegeFootballNews.com posted at foxsports.com
reports: Projected: 1st round. Good or bad move to
come out early? He would've been a first round pick last year.
Some teams will worry about the semi-nutty attitude, but others
will think it's an asset go along with his combination of hands
and speed.
Len Pasquarelli of
ESPN.com reports:Speaking of physical
measurements, Miami (Fla.) tight end Kellen Winslow Jr., son of
the Hall of Fame member, checked in at 6-feet-3 7/8 and 251
pounds. That was about a half-inch shorter than listed by the
Hurricanes, but right about where most scouts had him pegged.
There remains some disagreement over whether the younger Winslow
will be better lining up at the traditional tight end spot or at
an H-back type position. He is a very gifted route-runner, adept
at finding the open seam against a zone defense, but there are
lingering doubts about Winslow's ability as an in-line blocker.
Vic Ketchman of jaguars.com
reports: Winslow, a certain top 10 pick raised
his stock significantly with an impressive workout in Miami's
pro day. At 6-4, 251, Pauline says Winslow is “Jeremy Shockey
squared. He's a receiver in a tight end's body. Not a bad
blocker; gives effort in blocking. He creates mismatches; too
fast for linebackers and too big for defensive backs.”
The only knock on Winslow is that he's a high-maintenance player
who has a reputation for being arrogant and making stupid
remarks. “He's working to change that reputation,” Pauline (jaguars.com
draft expert) said. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
| Jones |
FS |
6-1¼,
215 |
4.55 |
4.05 |
11.13 |
6.90 |
16 |
36½" |
10-2 |
S
Jones
Georgia
#3 ranked FS by
Jaybird
|
Pete
Fiutak / CollegeFootballNews.com posted at foxsports.com
reports: Projected: 2nd to 3rd round.
Good or bad move to come out early? Jones has good size for a
safety with a linebacker ability against the run. He was always
around the ball this year and could be a high-rising prospect as
the draft nears.
NFLFans.com reports:
Jones is a playmaker that has excellent tools and
attitude to succeed in the pros. Many times juniors are unwise
to enter early, however, I do believe Sean is NFL ready and
should have an excellent career.
Mel Kiper of ESPN.com reports:
As the draft day countdown
approaches three weeks, Kiper has identified Jones as a fast
riser. |
| PLAYER |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE DRILL |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
| McCowan |
6-3
3/8, 208 |
4.63 |
4.21 |
6.74 |
37½" |
10-5 |
McCowan
La Tech
#10 ranked QB by
Jaybird
|
Ken Bikoff of
www.profootballweekly.com reports: Louisiana Tech QB
Luke McCown on the comparisons between him and his brother,
Josh, who has emerged as the best bet to be quarterbacking the
Cardinals next season. “We’re both calm individuals, both
athletic scramblers, but I’m a little bit more of a pocket
passer. Josh is more of a runner.”
Nolan Nawrocki of ProFootballWeekly.com
reports: Luke probably won’t be drafted on the
first day as his brother was (Josh). Yet he calmed some
scouts’ concerns by weighing in at 209, 12 pounds heavier than
he played in college. His athletic ability mirrors that of his
brother, who paced the competition in the 40-yard dash and
vertical jump among quarterbacks at the event two years ago. By
the conclusion of the Combine, Luke likely will have begun
inching up some teams’ draft boards. McCown and his older
brother will join the Manning brothers and Tim and Matt
Hasselbeck as the third set of brothers playing quarterback in
the NFL.
Gil Brandt of NFL.com reports: Luke
McCown, quarterback, Louisiana Tech. He's been out here since
the first day and has been throwing in nearly every drill. He
has taken advantage of helping out on drills (at the Combine)
showing scouts what he can do. McCown especially has looked
good.
Len Pasquarelli of ESPN.com reports:
Luke McCown threw the ball well at the Combine, and has
NFL-type physical stature.
NFLFans.com reports: McCowan
had an excellent showing at his pro day, throwing over 150
passes to WRs, RBs, & TEs. He was very impressive, and
reported as a hot prospect in NFL.com's pro day reports.
Brian DeLucia of
SportingNews.com reports: McCown has
good size and an above average arm. He possesses a good feeling
for timing routes and understands the game well. But for someone
with his intelligence and study habits, he makes some weird
reads and locks onto his primary target too often. McCown must
eliminate mistakes before he develops into a backup. If McCown
can work on making better reads and improve his accuracy, he
will be a solid backup and potential starter. Again, much of it
in his case will be how well he's coached at the pro level. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
| Gordon |
DE |
6-02.2,
302 |
5.02 |
1.72 |
4.42 |
7.55 |
21 |
31' |
9-4 |
Gordon
Stanford
Jaybird: below 4th round
|
Pete
Fiutak / CollegeFootballNews.com posted at foxsports.com
reports: Projected:
4th round to second day. Good or bad move to come out
early? An intriguing prospect, the former end turned tackle
could probably use another year to grow into more of a true
inside player. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
| Gallery |
G |
6.07.2,
310 |
5.52 |
- |
- |
- |
22 |
28½" |
8-7 |
Chambers
Stanford
Jaybird: below 4th round
|
D. J. Boyer of
Football.com reports: The offensive
line play was strong and a couple of prospects who looked like
day two picks may have moved into day one status (like OT Kirk
Chambers). Hard to pinpoint the big winner here (Combine), I say
Chambers and OT Sean Bubin of Illinois improved their stock the
most while OG Locklear was probably the best performer along the
line. |
| PLAYER |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
| Echemandu |
5-10
3/4, 226 |
4.52 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
15 |
- |
- |
Echemandu
California
#8 ranked RB by
Jaybird
|
Gil Brandt
of NFL.com reports: Echemandu is still recovering
from a broken fibula and did not work out at California's Pro
day. He will put on a work out on March 30.
Glenn Dickey of sfgate.com reports: Adimchinobe
Echemandu won't be among those NFL prospects working out at Cal
today for scouts, but he could be the steal of next month's
draft. The Cal running back rushed for 1,195 yards (5
yards per carry) and 13 touchdowns last season. The yardage
total is second in school history only to Chuck Muncie's 1,460
yards in 1975. Echemandu's 147 yards in Cal's upset of USC
marked the first time the Trojans' defense had yielded 100 yards
to a back in 17 games. With his combination of speed (4.3
in the 40 in a workout last summer) and power, in addition to
his blocking and receiving ability, Echemandu probably would
have been a low first-round or high second-round pick. In the
final game of the season, though, he twisted an ankle and
suffered a fibula fracture. His injury, to a non-weight-
bearing bone, is healing nicely, and a medical report predicts a
full recovery. Earlier, Echemandu had missed two seasons
because of academic ineligibility and an anterior cruciate
ligament (ACL) injury, but when he wasn't playing, he still
worked out with the team, so he witnessed the huge turnaround
when Jeff Tedford followed Tom Holmoe as coach. |
| PLAYER |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY |
10
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
| Geathers |
6-2,
211 |
4.45 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
14 |
- |
- |
Geathers
Miami
Jaybird: below 4th round
|
NFLFans.com
reports: Geathers was initially a RB behind McGahee
& Portis so had to switch to WR just to get on the field. He
may be raw in his techniques but will interest many scouts
because of the size, speed, and attitude he posses that will
allow him to develop into an excellent WR at the next level. He
is also an accomplished return man and has a good attitude to
contribute to special team assignments. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
| Osunde
(injury) |
O |
6.03.1,
252 |
4.80i |
4.65i |
- |
7.65i |
33 |
35½"i |
9-10i |
Osunde
Conneticut
#12 ranked OLB by
Jaybird
|
Mel Kiper
of ESPN.com reports: DE/OLB Uyi Osunde is a player
Kiper identified as an "under the radar" player.
NFLFans.com reports: One of
the true sleepers of the 2004 draft that recorded in his last 2
years 157 tackles, 30 TFL, and 20 sacks without even reaching
his top form as yet. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
| Buhl |
O |
5.11.1,
204 |
4.59 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
Buhl
Kansas State
Jaybird: below 4th round
|
Gil Brandt
of NFL.com reports: Kansas State's Josh Buhl ran
under 4.6 at the Combine.
NFLFans.com reports: Buhl
might be limited in gaining the size needed to play at LB in the
NFL but might be very successful if converted to the safety
position. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
| Hickman |
O |
6.07.7,
230 |
4.60 |
- |
11.57 |
7.01 |
26 |
33" |
9-1 |
Hickman
Kansas State
Jaybird: below 4th round
|
NFLFans.com
reports: OLB Hickman has constantly improved, and has
good upside. He could be a pleasant surprise as a mid day 2
selection. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
| Curry |
FS |
6-00.1,
204 |
4.68 |
- |
- |
- |
17 |
35" |
- |
Curry
Georgia
Jaybird: below 4th round
|
NFLFans.com
reports: FS Curry is highly regarded in SEC He is a
generally solid pass defender and tackler. However, he is
injury prone. His senior season marred by knee injury - which
caused Curry to be lost for the season. |
| PLAYER |
POS |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
| Grant |
SS |
- |
4.51 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
Grant
Mars Hill
Jaybird: below 4th round
|
Matt
Gambill of AllProScouting.com reports: In
keeping with the small school theme, Mars Hill SS/CB Michael
Grant is starting to make some moves up boards. The 5115,
205-pound defensive back finished with 36 tackles, 10 PBU, and 5
INT in 2003. Grant started his college career at Grambling, but
transferred to Georgia Southern and had to sit out because of
the lateral transfer rules. He didn't stay at GSU long before he
left for Ashville, N.C. where his family was starting a
ministry. Michael took the year to help his family get their
ministry off the ground and enrolled at Mars Hill. He's played
SS and CB and was named 1st Team All SAC and was invited to the
Cactus Bowl (D-2 all-star game). He's a very smooth, sleek
athlete in the secondary who is effective in the box, shows good
leverage in his pedal and can plant and turn fluidly. Shows good
transitional skills and instincts. Has the speed (4.51) to
mirror receivers. Grant is getting some late round grades from
some of the scouts I speak to and currently is the #9 SS on my
board. His versatility is making his value higher. A player who
needs some coaching, but could develop into a solid NFL player. |
TEAM NEWS/NEEDS
PRIOR TO THE DRAFT
Jay Goldberg of
90FootballLinks.NET reports:
major
need
need
position
possible
need, depth needed
no real need
Key UFA: Northcutt WR, Stokes T, O'Hara G, Boyer LB, Sanders CB,
Gardocki P
Key RFA: Zukauskas G (7th round)
NOTE - RFA COMPENSATION AT MINIMUM TENDER
QB: Couch
or Holcombe? Holcombe or Couch? Time to decide.
Personally, I'd go with Couch but give him a better line and a
true go-to receiver. If one of these two players is let
go, the Browns will need a reliable backup.
RB: I'll
be the first to admit it, I'm not a big William Green fan, and
that has to do with both on-field talent, and off-field issues.
On the other hand, in the right offense, I believe Jamel White
could be a very effective starter. Unfortunately for
White, the Browns preferred offense is not an ideal fit for him.
Therefore, Suggs should, and will, be the guy. And he will
will have a breakout year.
WR:
The Browns have a good stable of receivers. However,
none is a legit number one. Morgan, Davis and Northcutt
are all good players that teams would love to have, but is there
a player in that group that is a major worry for defensive
coordinators? Northcutt, because of speed and how he is
used, may situation-ally be the most worrisome. Northcutt
is also an UFA who is likely to leave. The Browns,
therefore, need a lead receiver and a receiver for their bench.
TE: The
Browns need an upgrade at tight end. There are a number of
players beyond the Winslow and Troupe in the draft who could
step in right away and upgrade the position.
OL:
Stokes and O'Hara are UFAs. The Browns would be
disappointed if Stokes was a starter next year anyway, and
O'Hara is serviceable, but better as a sub. Ideally, the
Browns would like to sign or draft a left tackle, have Verba
come back from injury and move inside to guard, and resign
O'Hara for depth. In any case, besides a left tackle look
for the Browns to also bring in at least one more guard.
DL: Brown
may not be the pass-rushing demon envisioned when he was
drafted, but he is still a good player. Warren has been a
mystery. He should be much better. Lang and Roye are
steady. An outside pass-rush specialist to play in the
nickel would help this unit.
LB: An interesting, young unit that should continue
to get better and better. I love Davis. He is a sure
tackler and a dangerous blitzer. Taylor and Bentley were
also a productive players. However, look for Thompson to
push Bentley for his starting job in camp. Boyer, an UFA,
should be resigned for depth, ability and to have an experienced
linebacker on the team.
DB:
Henry is a good corner and McCutcheon is okay. A player to
compete with McCutcheon would be helpful, and at worst, add
depth (especially with Sanders an UFA). I like the Browns
safeties. They compliment each other. Little has a
nose for the ball and Griffith hits like a truck. I'm not
sure, however, that Browns' management views their safeties the
same way. But then I don't see every play and count the
missed tackles.
D. J. Boyer of Football.com
reports: It
might be too early to speculate about something like this but it
seems like the Browns interest in Roethlisberger is even hotter
than first reported. So hot in fact that the Browns are toying
with the idea or may have already talked to the Raiders about
moving into the #2 spot in the first round. If this happens
expect the Raiders to try and land Shawn Andrews at tackle and
the deal from Cleveland would most likely involve a player like
Tim Couch or Quincy Morgan.
D. J. Boyer of
Football.com reports:
Ben Roethlisberger is here (at Senior
Bowl practice) making the rounds with Leigh Steinberg. 3 teams
showed immense interest in Roethlisberger...San
Diego...Cleveland....Dallas.
The Akron Beacon Journal's Terry Pluto
reports: the Cleveland Browns like Miami (Fla.)
safety Sean Taylor.
USAToday.com reports: The
Browns will pick seventh or eighth and would love to somehow
fall into Iowa left tackle Robert Gallery. It's not likely he'll
be on the board, though, so the Browns are taking a long look at
tight end Kellen Winslow Jr. and safety Sean Taylor, both from
the University of Miami.
|
2003
COLLEGE DRAFT
|
C+
|
2003
COLLEGE DRAFT REPORT CARD
|

|
| Faine is an excellent player. He will
anchor the Browns' offensive line for years. Thompson
was a good pick in round two. In some circles, picking
Thompson in round two might be considered a reach, but not
here. Thompson is versatile, has a load of talent, and
is a future NFL star. Excellent pick by the Browns.
The Browns selected Corker higher than where I thought he
would go. He has good physical skills, but there is some
question as to whether he will develop into a consistent NFL
starter. Suggs is an insurance policy in case Jamal
White leaves after this year. If White leaves, Suggs
should be ready to go in 2004. With Faine now on board,
Pontbriand backs him up and is their deep snapper. Lehan
has speed but needs to gain strength and improve his
technique. Garay was a very good value pick in round
seven. He can play tackle and end and should be a
valuable reserve and rotation player. |
| Faine |
WORKOUT
NUMBERS
Gil Brandt of NFL.com
reports, center Jeff Faine really impressed people. He
was listed at 6-foot-3, 298 pounds, and had a 33¼-inch arm
length. He ran a 4.9 and had a 1.68 in the 10-yard dash,
36-inch vertical jump, 10-foot long jump, 25 reps on the bench
press, 4.28 short shuttle, and 7.16 cone drill. Four offensive
line coaches worked him out pretty good. His stock elevated
today. |
| Thompson |
AllProScouting.com
reports in pre-combine workouts, West
Texas A&M OLB Chaun Thompson is running in the low 4.4 s
on grass at 233-pounds.
Chaun Thompson, West Texas
A&M -- Ran 4.48 in the 40... at Draft2003.com reports,
6-foot-2, 240 pounds... had 35" vertical... did 29 reps
of 225 pounds... and was solid in his drills... was viewed at
both linebacker spots... that increased his stock, as well...
Matt Gambill of AllProScouting.com reports, an
update on a player I have been high on since October. West
Texas A&M LB Chaun Thompson's post season momentum has
continued. The 6017, 240-pound LB with 4.4/4.5 speed is
scheduled to workout in Canyon, Texas on March 13th at 11am in
front of at least 15 teams. Chaun has been rated as my #2 OLB
prospect for three months now and he's established himself as
a solid first day prospect with a tremendous upside. He's
moves very well laterally, shows a tremendous burst in
pursuit, locates the ball well, shows good change of direction
skills, balance, and understands the game very well. He can
also kick off. Very good looking prospect.
Matt Gambill of AllProScouting.com
reports, athletically speaking, Thompson is a first round
talent, but teams will worry about his technique on shedding
blocks and his consistency with his hands. These are all
things that are minor and are coachable. I think when it's all
said and done, he will be a 2nd or 3rd rounder.
Matt Gambill of
AllProScouting.com reports, Chaun
Thompson continued to impress with another fabulous positional
workout. The Bucs, Texans, and Redskins all had their LB
coaches there and Green Bay sent their Personnel Director,
Mark Hatley. He showed very well in his drops, as well as
explosiveness in a short area and a burst to move sideline to
sideline. He did well in flexibility drills and had an
outstanding day. Most teams project Chaun as a WLB at the next
level. Hatley was said to have taken Chaun to lunch
where the two had a great conversation and Hatley came away
impressed with Chaun's personality and playmaking abilities.
Matt Gambill of
AllProScouting.com reports, I have
Chaun Thompson as my #14 rated Senior Prospect. One thing
people can't seem to comprehend is that scouting is a three
year process. Projections are based on PRO POTENTIAL, UPSIDE,
and WHERE THE PLAYER WILL BE THREE YEARS DOWN THE ROAD. |
| Suggs |
Len Pasquarelli of ESPN.com
reports that one guy who could emerge at the running back
position is Lee Suggs of Virginia Tech who has vowed to show
up at the combine at 215 pounds, 10-12 more than his usual
playing weight. Suggs could jump to the front of the tailback
class with a good spring. More than a mere weight gain,
though, Suggs is going to have to run a good 40-yard time to
make a move up the draft boards
Gil Brandt of NFL.com reported Lee Suggs
of Virginia Tech measured 5-11 5/8, 202 at the combine.
WORKOUT
NUMBERS
Matt Gambill of AllProScouting.com reports, Suggs
was 204-pounds and ran mid-high 4.4's. He had a 36 1/2
vertical and 10'3 broad jump.
Great
Blue North (GBNReport.com) reports, Virginia Tech RB Lee
Suggs, reportedly had a strong workout in Blacksburg, running
the 40 in 4.45 and catching everything thrown his way in
passing drills. Suggs measured in at just under 6-0 and 204
pounds. There are some concerns, though, about a lingering
shoulder problem that kept Suggs from working out at the
combines in Indianapolis last month. Suggs, of course, also
suffered a torn ACL in 2001, but bounced back nicely this past
fall. |
| Garay |
WORKOUT
NUMBERS
Gil Brandt of NFL.com reports,
Antonio Garay was 6-3¾ and 295 pounds. He ran the 40 twice
for 4.95 and 5.0 seconds. He did a vertical of 29½ inches, a
long jump of 7-foot-10, a 4.48 in the short shuttle, and a
7.43 in the three-cone drill. |
2002
COLLEGE DRAFT
|
GRADE : C
I would have taken
Duckett over Green. Time will tell whether Green becomes
a true number one back or settles in a notch below (Rhett,
Murrell, Stewart, Dayne, etc.). Duckett will be a stud.
Davis is good and will contribute, Cliff Russell may have
helped more. Fowler was a solid pick in the third round.
LBs Bentley, Taylor and Davis add defensive depth and special
team skills. TE Sanders could be a sleeper. He can
run block and has the skills to develop as a receiving threat.
Don't count out OT Gonzalez.
Links
below take you to NFL.com's report on player, position or
college team.
Click
here to go to 900 Football Links prospect news to check out
more info
|
|